All cases
Sign in
The Bargain Basement — Anthony Pignataro

Anthony Pignataro: The Bargain Basement

The Bargain Basement:AccusedAnthony Pignataro·VictimsSarah Smith·Deborah Pignataro·Terri LaMarti

Case at a glance

When
August 1997 (Sarah Smith’s surgery) and 1999 (the arsenic poisoning)
Where
West Seneca, New York, near Buffalo
Perpetrator
Anthony Pignataro, who legally changed his name to Anthony “Tony” Haute in 2016
Outcome
Pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide in June 1998 and served a six-month jail term; pleaded guilty in November 2000 to first-degree assault for poisoning his wife and was sentenced to 15 years; released from prison in December 2013

The case

Anthony Pignataro ran a cosmetic surgery practice out of the basement of a former dental office in West Seneca, New York, outside Buffalo. He advertised bargain breast augmentations and drove a red Lamborghini. He was not a board-certified plastic surgeon, he employed no anesthesiologist, and his makeshift operating room had no ventilator. In June 1997 a patient named Terri LaMarti nearly bled to death after surgery there.

On August 25, 1997, twenty-six-year-old Sarah Smith, a mother of two, stopped breathing on his table after he gave her heavy doses of anesthetic drugs. He tried to force an airway open with a bent wire coat hanger. She went into cardiac arrest and died at a hospital on September 1, 1997, of asphyxiation caused by improper ventilation. Pignataro pleaded guilty in June 1998 to criminally negligent homicide, drew six months in jail, a fine and probation, and lost his medical license for good.

He was out by December 1998. The next spring his wife, Deborah, began losing feeling in her hands and feet; testing found the highest arsenic level New York State had ever recorded in a living patient. He pleaded guilty in November 2000 to first-degree assault for poisoning her and was sentenced to fifteen years. Released in December 2013, he legally changed his name to Anthony Haute in 2016.

Case photographs

Anthony and Deborah Pignataro
Anthony and Deborah Pignataro
Anthony and Deborah Pignataro
Anthony and Deborah Pignataro
Anthony Pignataro
Anthony Pignataro
Anthony Pignataro
Anthony Pignataro
Anthony Pignataro
Anthony Pignataro
Pignataro’s patent drawing
Pignataro’s patent drawing

Where it happened

West Seneca, where Pignataro operated in a basement

Jason Neal has been writing true crime since 2019 and is the author of the True Crime Case Histories book series.

The full written account of this case is in True Crime Case Histories: Volume 21: Book · Paperback · Audiobook

Loading…
Preview over

There’s more to this one.

Start a 3-day free trial and hear the rest of this story, plus any four others. Cancel any time before it ends and you pay nothing.

Start your free trial 3 days free, then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year