All cases
Try 3 days free True CrimeCase Histories Sign in
Category

Child Victims

These cases involve victims under eighteen. They are among the hardest stories in the series, and they are written with that in mind: the focus is on what happened, how the case was solved and what justice followed, not on graphic detail. Many of these cases changed laws, alert systems or the way police handle reports involving children. The children at the center of them are remembered by name, as their families wanted, and several of the stories include the work those families went on to do.

Cases in this category

The Vanishing Act — Elmer Crawford

The Vanishing Act

In July 1970 the Crawford family car was found at the bottom of Loch Ard Gorge with a mother and her three children inside, staged to look like a murder-suicide. Their father, Elmer Crawford, was seen at home that day and never again.

The Monster of the Andes — Pedro Alonso López

The Monster of the Andes

In 1980 a crowd in an Ecuadorian market town held a stranger who was leading a young girl away. Pedro Alonso López went on to show police the graves of 53 girls, served 14 years, and walked out of a Colombian hospital in 1998. No one knows where he is.

It Couldn’t Be Helped — William Gravlin

It Couldn’t Be Helped

A week after his wife asked for a divorce, former firefighter William Gravlin took a taxi back to the family home in Troy, Michigan. By morning his wife and six children were dead, each covered with a blanket and a note of apology.

No Fire, No Food — Aaron Bacon

No Fire, No Food

In March 1994, North Star Expeditions staff pulled sixteen-year-old Aaron Bacon from his Phoenix bed and drove him to Utah's remote Escalante canyon country, where the wilderness program's rules said no food sharing — and no fire until you earned it.

The Gum Ruse — Mitchell Gaff

The Gum Ruse

Susan Vesey celebrated her twenty-first birthday in Everett, Washington, in July 1980. By morning she was dead on her bedroom floor, her infant son unharmed beside her — and the case would stay cold for decades.

The Sleepover — Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman

The Sleepover

Ashley Freeman turned sixteen on December 29, 1999, and her best friend Lauria Bible stayed over at the family trailer near Welch, Oklahoma. Before dawn the trailer was in flames, and the two girls were gone.

Hurtcore — Matthew Graham

Hurtcore

Behind a closed bedroom door in suburban Melbourne, a quiet former babysitter named Matthew Graham ran the dark web's most notorious child-abuse network under the name Lux — until investigators on three continents started pulling the thread.

Keep Digging — Tony Costa

Keep Digging

Pat Walsh and Mary Anne Wysocki drove to wintry Provincetown for a weekend getaway in January 1969 and never came home — and the search for them would lead into the dunes and secrets of Tony Costa's Cape Cod.

Bad John — Johnny Lee Thornton

Bad John

Four teenagers left a Fort Leonard Wood card game to find pizza and gas on a January night in 1977. On the dark roads of the Missouri military base, they met military policeman Johnny Lee Thornton.

Mockingbird Hill — Ronald Gene Simmons

Mockingbird Hill

On a December morning in 1987, a man in a black coat and cowboy hat shot receptionist Kathy Kendrick in a Russellville law office and drove off toward the next name on his list — and what Ronald Gene Simmons had already done at Mockingbird Hill was worse.

The Lonely Hearts Killers — The Lonely Hearts Killers

The Lonely Hearts Killers

After a ship's hatch fractured his skull, Raymond Fernandez emerged a changed and dangerous man — one who trawled the lonely hearts columns and, with Martha Beck, left a trail of widows across postwar America.

The Speed Freaks — The Speed Freak Killers

The Speed Freaks

Wesley Shermantine and Loren Herzog grew up inseparable across Fine Road in tiny Linden, California. What the two friends did in the methamphetamine years would leave San Joaquin County digging for victims decades later.

Fourteen Days — The Bitter Blood Murders

Fourteen Days

Patients in Reidsville, North Carolina, trusted 'Young Dr. Klenner' with their lives — but Fritz Klenner had never attended medical school, and his years of deception would end in a trail of dead across two families.

Middle Mountain — Mark Redwine

Middle Mountain

Thirteen-year-old Dylan Redwine flew to Colorado for a court-ordered Thanksgiving visit with his father, Mark, at a remote house near Vallecito Reservoir. By morning, the boy who always texted back was gone.

The Kite Flyer — Mark Dean Schwab

The Kite Flyer

Eleven-year-old Junny Rios-Martinez made the local paper when he won a kite contest on Florida's Space Coast. The very next day, a man calling himself a Florida Today photographer phoned his family asking to meet the young champion.

The Killing Cousins — The Killing Cousins

The Killing Cousins

Fifteen-year-old Michael Rock was riding his bike past a Vero Beach house in July 1983 when a naked, bound teenage girl came running down the gravel driveway, screaming — with a large man in pursuit.

The Vanishing Act — John List

The Vanishing Act

When police climbed through a window of the darkened List mansion in Westfield, New Jersey, in December 1971, the house was ice cold, the family had been 'away' for a month — and church hymns were still playing over the intercom.

The Broken Arrow Massacre — The Bever Family Murders

The Broken Arrow Massacre

A whispered 911 call from a Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, home began: 'My brother's attacking my family.' Then the screaming stopped, a male voice said hello, and the line went dead.

The Kennedale Murders — John Hummel

The Kennedale Murders

Eight days before Christmas 2009, a house fire lit up a quiet street in Kennedale, Texas — the home of John Hummel, his wife Joy, their five-year-old daughter, and Joy's father. Investigators soon realized the fire was only the cover story.

The Lakewood Monster — Guy Rasmussen

The Lakewood Monster

On the Fourth of July 1996, nine-year-old Cynthia Allinger left her Lakewood, Washington, apartment in her favorite flowered dress to visit friends nearby. By the time the fireworks faded, she still hadn't come home.

Over Our Dead Bodies — Debora Green

Over Our Dead Bodies

When fire tore through the Prairie Village, Kansas, mansion of physician Debora Green in October 1995, her children were still inside — and investigators would learn the flames were not the family's first brush with poison and ruin.

The All-American Monster — John Norman Collins

The All-American Monster

Accounting student Mary Fleszar stepped out for fresh air on a July evening in Ypsilanti in 1967 and vanished — the first of the coeds whose deaths would terrorize Eastern Michigan University for two years.

The Middletown Nightmare — Valerie Smelser

The Middletown Nightmare

Twelve-year-old Valerie Smelser vanished from a Virginia gas station restroom on a freezing January night in 1995. The story told by Norman Hoverter, the man traveling with her mother, would soon begin to unravel.

The Perfect Murder — Maria Baumer

The Perfect Murder

Mushroom foragers in a Bavarian forest near Regensburg found bones fused with hardened quicklime — remains someone had tried to chemically erase. Christian F. believed he had committed the perfect murder.

The Bargain Basement — Anthony Pignataro

The Bargain Basement

Dr. Anthony Pignataro cruised Buffalo in a red Lamborghini selling cut-rate cosmetic surgery. In his makeshift basement operating room, paramedics found patient Sarah Smith dying — and the doctor holding a bent coat hanger.

They'll Blame Us — Genny Rojas

They'll Blame Us

When four-year-old Genny Rojas was found burned and lifeless in her aunt and uncle's Chula Vista apartment, Veronica Gonzales begged the neighbors not to call police — and she and her husband Ivan each had a story to tell.

The Cleveland Monster — Ariel Castro

The Cleveland Monster

Michelle Knight was rushing to a custody hearing in 2002 when a familiar Cleveland school bus driver named Ariel Castro offered her a ride — with a quick stop at his ordinary-looking house on Seymour Avenue.

The Hammer Killer — Alex Christopher Ewing

The Hammer Killer

In January 1984, residents of Aurora, Colorado, began waking to a nightmare: an intruder standing over their beds with a hammer. The attacks were only the beginning of a spree that would take decades to unravel.

Silent Screams — Autumn Hallow

Silent Screams

Sarah Hallow's frantic 911 call said her stepdaughter had drowned in the bathtub — but when Elk River officers reached eight-year-old Autumn Hallow, her skin was dry, her body frail, and rigor mortis had already set in.

The Digital Trail — Benjamin Fawley

The Digital Trail

Seventeen-year-old Taylor Behl arrived at Virginia Commonwealth University brimming with excitement for college life. She had no idea that Ben Fawley — a 38-year-old 'goth' photographer whose apartment was a shrine to death — was watching her.

The Smooth Talker — Roy Melanson

The Smooth Talker

On a July night in 1974, a charming stranger lingered at the bar of Fagiani's Cocktail Lounge in Napa as Anita Andrews closed up alone. It would take decades to learn who the smooth talker really was.

The Gilbert Goons — Preston Lord

The Gilbert Goons

Sixteen-year-old Preston Lord was walking away from a Halloween party in Queen Creek, Arizona, when a mob of teenagers descended. The beating exposed months of organized violence festering beneath Gilbert's wealthy suburban surface.

The Baseline Killer — Mark Goudeau

The Baseline Killer

It began on Baseline Road in Phoenix in August 2005, when a calm stranger with a silver handgun ambushed three children walking home from church — the first attack in one of Arizona's most terrifying crime sprees.

The Crown Hill Murder — Nathan Matthews

The Crown Hill Murder

Sixteen-year-old Becky Watts was home alone in Bristol's Crown Hill neighborhood on an ordinary Thursday in February 2015. By evening she had vanished — and the search would lead somewhere her family never imagined.

The Viking Princess — Tanner Horner

The Viking Princess

Seven-year-old Athena Strand, who dreamed of being a Viking princess in pink armor, hopped off the school bus near her home in Paradise, Texas, in November 2022. By nightfall she was missing — and the search led to a delivery driver named Tanner Horner.

The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders — The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders

The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders

Best friends Jasmin and Yvonne, both sixteen, left a German discotheque at 3:00 a.m. in October 1994 and accepted a ride from a friendly middle-aged couple — a motherly woman and her quiet husband. Neither girl made it home to Limburg.

The Witch's Castle — Shanda Sharer

The Witch's Castle

Hunters walking a frozen Indiana soybean field in January 1992 thought they had found a burned mannequin. It was twelve-year-old Shanda Sharer — and those responsible were four teenage girls, drawn together by jealousy over a single classmate.

The Forbidden Closet — Michele Kalina

The Forbidden Closet

For years, Michele Kalina kept one closet in the family's Reading, Pennsylvania apartment locked, forbidding her daughter ever to look inside. In July 2010, nineteen-year-old Elizabeth finally opened it — and called 911 about what she found in a cooler.

The Long Walk Home — Richard Archibeque

The Long Walk Home

Seventeen-year-old Mary Quigley never made it home from a back-to-school keg party in Santa Clara, California, in September 1977. For decades the question of who followed her into the night went unanswered — until DNA pointed to a name: Richard Archibeque.

The Waterbed — Joshua Phillips

The Waterbed

Eight-year-old Maddie Clifton finished her piano practice and went out to play in her Jacksonville neighborhood on November 3, 1998, then vanished. For days, hundreds searched — while the answer lay closer to home than anyone could bear to imagine.

Count to Three — Skylar Neese

Count to Three

A security camera caught sixteen-year-old Skylar Neese slipping out her bedroom window at 12:30 a.m. and climbing into a waiting car in Star City, West Virginia. She knew the people inside — which made what happened next all the more incomprehensible.

Bail Granted — Andrew Bagby

Bail Granted

Dr. Andrew Bagby, a young physician beloved by his Pennsylvania patients, was found dead after ending his turbulent relationship with Shirley Turner, a medical-school classmate twelve years his senior. She fled to Newfoundland — carrying Andrew's unborn son.

Langworthy Road — Suzanne Capper

Langworthy Road

Two motorists on a country lane outside Manchester stopped for a horribly burned girl staggering toward the road. 'Help me. I'm Suzanne Capper,' she rasped — then named every one of her tormentors, exposing a week of horror at 97 Langworthy Road.

The Vanishing — Stuart Knowlton

The Vanishing

During a family night program at a St. Paul church in November 1981, six-year-old Cassie Hansen asked her mother for permission to use the bathroom just steps away. She never came back — and an abduction inside a sanctuary changed how the city thought about safety.

He Needed Killing — Ken McElroy

He Needed Killing

For years, Ken McElroy terrorized the tiny farming town of Skidmore, Missouri, shrugging off charge after charge. Then, in broad daylight on the town's main street, someone shot the bully — in front of dozens of witnesses who all claimed to have seen nothing.

The Millionaire — Christopher Foster

The Millionaire

Millionaire Christopher Foster spent August 25, 2008, shooting clay pigeons and relaxing at a neighbor's barbecue with his wife Jill and daughter Kirstie. By sunrise, their Shropshire mansion, Osbaston House, was a smoldering ruin concealing the truth of his collapsing empire.

Friendly Reminders — Erica Parsons

Friendly Reminders

No one outside the family noticed that thirteen-year-old Erica Parsons had been missing for a year and a half — until her adoptive brother Jamie, kicked out after a fierce argument, walked into the Rowan County Sheriff's Office with a chilling accusation about their parents.

The Highway of Tears — Cody Legebokoff

The Highway of Tears

On a snowy November night in 2010, an RCMP officer watched a black pickup fishtail out of a deserted logging road near British Columbia's infamous Highway of Tears. The young driver, Cody Legebokoff, had blood on his face — and a story that didn't add up.

The Christadelphian — Gary Schaefer

The Christadelphian

Springfield, Vermont, seemed like a postcard New England town until thirteen-year-old Sherry Nastasia vanished in August 1979. Over the next four years more young girls were taken — and the clue that finally broke the case was a church sweatshirt.

Sacred Trust — Danny Croteau

Sacred Trust

Thirteen-year-old Danny Croteau was found dead along the Chicopee River in 1972, and suspicion quickly settled on a family friend no one dared accuse: Father Richard Lavigne, the parish priest. The case would stay open for nearly fifty years.

The Krug Park Killers — Kaytlin Root

The Krug Park Killers

A jogger's trembling 911 call one October morning in 2016 reported a body on a trail in St. Joseph, Missouri's Krug Park. Seventeen-year-old Kaytlin Root had been lured there by a Facebook message from someone calling herself 'Amanda Panda.'

The Bedroom Basher — Gerald Parker

The Bedroom Basher

While Marine Kevin Green stepped out for late-night food in September 1979, someone entered his Tustin, California apartment and savagely beat his pregnant wife, Dianna. She survived with shattered memories — and what she remembered would cost Kevin sixteen years.

The Frankston Serial Killer — Paul Denyer

The Frankston Serial Killer

In the winter of 1993, the seaside Melbourne suburb of Frankston lived in terror as three young women — a student, a new mother out buying milk, a girl taking a shortcut home — were murdered in a matter of weeks. A yellow Toyota spotted near a bike path changed everything.

The Griekwastad Farm Murders — Don Steenkamp

The Griekwastad Farm Murders

On Good Friday 2012, fifteen-year-old Don Steenkamp burst into the Griekwastad police station drenched in blood, telling officers he had found his parents and sister shot on the family farm. The question was what had really happened inside that farmhouse.

The Demon — David Minto

The Demon

Sasha Marsden of the quiet village of Staining, England, was known for spontaneous dance moves and an infectious sense of humor. In nearby Blackpool, a hotel job offer from a man named David Minto was waiting — an offer that concealed something monstrous.

A Killer Breakthrough — Colin Pitchfork

A Killer Breakthrough

Fifteen-year-old Lynda Mann took the Black Pad footpath to a babysitting job in Narborough, England, one November evening in 1983 and never came home. Solving her murder — and a second one nearby — would require a scientific technique no police force had ever used.

The Slumber Party — Sandi Nieves

The Slumber Party

After her bitter second divorce, Sandi Nieves gathered her daughters for a special slumber party, letting them fall asleep together in the kitchen of their California home. What the morning brought would put her at the center of one of the state's most disturbing trials.

The Castle Doctrine — Byron Smith

The Castle Doctrine

On Thanksgiving Day 2012, two teenagers slipped into the basement of Byron Smith's secluded home in Little Falls, Minnesota. What the retired security engineer did next — with an audio recorder running — ignited a national debate over how far self-defense can go.

The South Side Strangler — Timothy Wilson Spencer

The South Side Strangler

A car left running all night on a quiet Richmond street led police to Debbie Davis's apartment in September 1987 — the first in a series of brutal stranglings across Virginia that would push detectives toward a brand-new forensic tool called DNA.

The Cape Coral Monster — Joseph Zieler

The Cape Coral Monster

Jan Cornell rushed home before her early-morning shift in May 1990 to find her Cape Coral townhouse silent — her eleven-year-old daughter Robin and roommate Lisa Story inside. The DNA left behind would wait twenty-six years for a match.

The City Planner — Robert Anthony Buell

The City Planner

Twelve-year-old Tina Marie Harmon stopped for a fudgesicle in Creston, Ohio, and never caught up with her friends. Two men were charged in her death — while matching orange carpet fibers kept turning up wherever more young girls were found.

Collateral Damage — Douglas Garland

Collateral Damage

Five-year-old Nathan O'Brien begged to sleep over at his grandparents' Calgary home the night of their estate sale in June 2014. When his mother returned the next morning, Nathan, Alvin, and Kathy Liknes were gone — and the house told a grim story.

The Zombie Hunter — Bryan Patrick Miller

The Zombie Hunter

The day before her twenty-second birthday, Angela Brosso set off on a five-mile bike ride along a Phoenix canal near her home and never came back. For more than two decades, the canal killings haunted the Sunnyslope neighborhood.

The Leaf Killer — Matthew Hoffman

The Leaf Killer

When Tina Herrmann missed her shift at the Mount Vernon Dairy Queen, her manager drove out to check on her — and found a house full of blood but no trace of Tina, her two children, or her friend Stephanie Sprang.

The Creepy Uncle — Stuart Campbell

The Creepy Uncle

Fifteen-year-old Danielle Jones left for her school bus stop in East Tilbury, Essex, and vanished. Witnesses saw a girl in uniform arguing with a man in a blue van — a van that belonged to her own uncle, Stuart Campbell.

Folly Beach — Richard Valenti

Folly Beach

In May 1973, fourteen-year-old Alexis Latimer and her best friend Sherri Clark took one last stroll down Folly Beach before dark. Police insisted the girls had run off with boys — until more young women were attacked in the sleepy South Carolina beach town.

Mr. Big — Brett Peter Cowan

Mr. Big

Thirteen-year-old Daniel Morcombe stood beneath a Queensland overpass in December 2003, waiting for a bus that had broken down. When the next bus arrived ten minutes later, Daniel — and the man seen lingering behind him — had vanished.

The River Brent Killer — Alice Gross

The River Brent Killer

On a warm August afternoon in 2014, fourteen-year-old Alice Gross texted her father that she was heading home along West London's canal towpath. Dinner came and went, and Alice never arrived — and the search would lead police to a Latvian immigrant with a dark past.

The Crossword Murder — Lars Bense

The Crossword Murder

Seven-year-old Lars Bense set off through the snow to meet friends at the cinema in Halle-Neustadt, East Germany — a planned city of numbered concrete blocks with no street names. He vanished in the final few hundred feet, and the strangest clue would be a crossword puzzle.

Better Off in Heaven — Laurel Schlemmer

Better Off in Heaven

To her Pittsburgh-area church and school colleagues, Laurel Schlemmer was sweet, kind-hearted, and devout — a woman who had never wanted the children her husband Mark insisted on. One morning, with their grandmother watching television downstairs, Laurel ran a bath for the boys.

The Groomer — Kayleigh Haywood

The Groomer

'Hi, how are you? I've seen your picture. You're very pretty.' The Facebook message that reached fifteen-year-old Kayleigh Haywood on Halloween 2015 came from twenty-seven-year-old Luke Harlow — and thirteen days of hidden messages convinced her she was loved.

The Screwdriver Killer — George Davies

The Screwdriver Killer

In 1957, Connecticut's George Davies answered a newspaper ad — 'French girl desires light housekeeping' — with devious intentions. Seventeen-year-old Gaetane Boivin left a note about a job opportunity and never came home; days later, nine-year-old Brenda Jane Doucette vanished walking to school.

The Fifth Nail — Joseph Edward Duncan III

The Fifth Nail

A Wolf Lodge, Idaho, man called 911 about a strange white truck on his property; hours later he called back, frantic, after finding blood smeared on his neighbors' door. Inside the Groene home, deputies found bodies bound with duct tape — and the youngest children gone.

Tony the Pervert — Shaun “Tony” Armstrong

Tony the Pervert

Three-year-old Rosie Palmer bought an ice pop from the ice cream van outside her Hartlepool, England home and vanished within the hour. Police went door to door; a few houses away, Shaun 'Tony' Armstrong told them he hadn't seen her, and they moved on.

The Sunday School Teacher — Melissa Huckaby

The Sunday School Teacher

Eight-year-old Sandra Cantu skipped across the street outside her Tracy, California mobile home park on March 27, 2009, and was never seen again. At a community vigil, a tearful Sunday school teacher named Melissa Huckaby pressed a note into the hands of police.

The Leg Thing — Joe Clark

The Leg Thing

Fourteen-year-old Chris Steiner vanished from his Baraboo, Wisconsin home on the night of July 4, 1994, leaving a window screen cut from the outside and muddy footprints on the carpet. A year later, thirteen-year-old Thad Phillips woke to find himself being carried into the dark.

Vanished Innocence — Mona Rae Minyard

Vanished Innocence

Two days after Christmas 1962, six-year-old Mona Rae Minyard walked to Portland's Three Brothers Market with a five-dollar bill and her mother's short grocery list. She never came home — and suspicion settled on Joseph Walton Holmes, the man who lived just across the field.

Touchdowns and Pom-Poms — William Riley Gaul

Touchdowns and Pom-Poms

Freshman cheerleader Emma Walker and senior football star Riley Gaul were Central High School's picture-perfect couple in Knoxville, Tennessee — he the polite boy next door, she a girl dreaming of nursing newborns. Her parents' fondness for Riley wouldn't survive what came next.

The Revolving Doors — Charles Ray Hatcher

The Revolving Doors

Born to a bootlegger's family in small-town Missouri, Charles Ray Hatcher grew from a bullied, brutalized boy into a cold and remorseless predator. His life became a revolving door through America's prisons — and the danger returned each time the door swung open.

The Kuwaiti Wedding — Nasra al-Enezi

The Kuwaiti Wedding

Nasra al-Enezi's mental illness went undiagnosed her whole life in Kuwait, where stigma kept her suffering in silence as she raised two special-needs sons. When her husband Zayed decided to take a second wife, the wedding celebration ended in catastrophe.

A Sad Holiday Season — John Taylor

A Sad Holiday Season

Sixteen-year-old Leanne Tiernan said goodbye to her best friend after a day of Christmas shopping in Leeds and took the unlit shortcut through Houghley Gill. Police searched 1,400 houses, drained three miles of canals, and questioned 140 men — and found no trace of her.

The Closet — Mary Rowles

The Closet

At 3:00 a.m. in Akron, Ohio, patrol officers found three emaciated, shoeless boys wandering the sidewalk, drinking from garden hoses and digging through trash cans. Over foot-long sandwiches — the best food they'd ever tasted — the brothers began to explain what their lives had been.

A Perfect Holiday — Lianne Smith

A Perfect Holiday

Failed stage hypnotist Martin Smith controlled every corner of Lianne's life — even after his crimes surfaced and the family fled Britain for Spain under false names. For her children, Rebecca and Daniel, the perfect holiday their mother promised would be their last.

The Girl Scout — David Westerfield

The Girl Scout

Selling Girl Scout cookies door to door in Sabre Springs, California, Brenda van Dam and seven-year-old Danielle stopped at the immaculate home of wealthy neighbor David Westerfield — who bought cookies, showed off his kitchen, and mentioned his 'adult parties.' That weekend, Danielle vanished.

Wheres Savanna — Savanna LaFontaine-Greywind

Wheres Savanna

Nursing student Savanna Greywind, twenty-two and pregnant, lived with her close-knit family in a Fargo apartment building where neighbors rarely got past hello in the hallway. Then the woman from the third floor knocked on the Greywinds' door — and Savanna answered.

The Bushy-Haired Stranger — Frank Jarvis Atwood

The Bushy-Haired Stranger

Eight-year-old Vicki Lynne Hoskinson pedaled her pink Christmas bicycle two blocks to mail a birthday card in Tucson, Arizona, in September 1984. Minutes later, her sister found the bike lying in the middle of the road — and no sign of Vicki.

They Got in the Way — Louise Porton

They Got in the Way

Louise Porton had been an angry outsider since childhood near Birmingham, England; by eighteen she was openly selling sex and bragging about the money. Motherhood arrived in the form of two little daughters — and Louise came to see them as obstacles.

The Conman — Christopher Hightower

The Conman

In September 1991, lawyer Ernest Brendel, his librarian wife Alice, and their eight-year-old daughter Emily vanished without a trace from Barrington, Rhode Island. Six weeks later, the sleepy town learned it had been living with a sociopath in its midst: Christopher Hightower.

Worlds Worst Mom — Theresa Knorr

Worlds Worst Mom

Driving near Lake Tahoe at dawn in June 1984, Maybel Harrison spotted flames beside the highway: a young woman burning on a makeshift pyre, bound, gagged, and unidentifiable. Nearly a decade later, Terry Knorr told police a story about her own family that no one believed.

The Murder of Stephanie Hebert — Stephanie Hebert

The Murder of Stephanie Hebert

Five-year-old Stephanie Hebert set off for a friend's house three doors down Aster Lane in Waggaman, Louisiana, in June 1978 — and never made it. More than 150 deputies searched the canals and levees for the little girl in baby-blue glasses without finding a trace.

The Eagle Scout — John Joubert

The Eagle Scout

Thirteen-year-old paperboy Danny Joe Eberle vanished from his Bellevue, Nebraska route one Sunday morning in 1983, leaving behind his beloved BMX bike and a bag of undelivered newspapers. Just thirteen days earlier, another paperboy had disappeared two hours away in Des Moines.

Baby Lollipops — Ana Maria Cardona

Baby Lollipops

A utility crew working along Miami's North Bay Road spotted what looked like a candy wrapper behind a hedge. It was a lollipop decal on a tiny shirt — worn by a battered, starved toddler no one could identify, a boy the case would name Baby Lollipops.

Pied Piper of Tucson — Charles Schmid

Pied Piper of Tucson

Charles 'Smitty' Schmid stuffed his cowboy boots with crushed cans, wore pancake makeup, and painted on a fake mole — and Tucson's teenagers followed him anyway. Then he told Mary French he wanted to know what killing felt like, and asked her to pick the girl.

The Slumber Party — Jeremy Gipson

The Slumber Party

At a sleepover just a few houses from home in Louisville, twelve-year-old Jessica Thornsberry opened the front door around 11:00 p.m. and whispered that the neighborhood boys were back. Her best friend April told her to send them away — and never saw her alive again.

Beyond Redemption — Justina Morley

Beyond Redemption

Sixteen-year-old Jason Sweeney saved every paycheck from his father's construction company to pay for military academy — his first step toward becoming a Navy SEAL. In Philadelphia's Fishtown, his lifelong best friend Eddie Batzig and the Coia brothers were growing jealous of every dollar.

Angelic — Daniel Holdom

Angelic

In 2008, Karlie Pearce-Stevenson left remote Alice Springs with her toddler, Khandalyce, and a boyfriend fifteen years her senior, Daniel Holdom. A year later her calls and texts home stopped — though her bank account stayed strangely active.

Slayer's Book of Death — Jason Massey

Slayer's Book of Death

Texas teenager Jason Massey tortured animals to feed the urges festering inside him and filled notebooks with fantasies of death. When a younger boy asked him for a ride to see his girlfriend, thirteen-year-old Christina Benjamin, Massey started making plans of his own.

Like Mother, Like Son — Cheryl Kunkle

Like Mother, Like Son

In Pennsylvania's Pocono Mountains, Cheryl Kunkle raised her son Greg Rowe on resentment and control. When sixteen-year-old Kristin Fisher refused the abortion Greg demanded and gave birth to baby Kaylee, mother and son came to share far more than a grudge.

A Heartless Mother — Ellen Boehm

A Heartless Mother

After her young son David died, St. Louis mother Ellen Boehm bought a new car rather than pay his $2,348 funeral bill — and seemed more upbeat than ever. She still held a $5,000 life insurance policy on each of her surviving children.

The Family Murders — Bevan Spencer von Einem

The Family Murders

In 1972, Bevan Spencer von Einem was hailed a hero for rescuing two men thrown into Adelaide's River Torrens. Seven years later, sixteen-year-old Alan Barnes stuck out his thumb on Grand Junction Road to hitch a ride home — and never arrived.

The Llama Farm Murder — Sky McDonough

The Llama Farm Murder

Seventeen-year-old Leanna Walker told friends she planned to run away with Sky McDonough, a self-styled Rastafarian who quoted Bible verses about killing a wife who leaves. When she vanished from Milford, Pennsylvania, the search closed in on the woods around a llama farm.

The Killer Cop — Gerard John Schaefer

The Killer Cop

When a sheriff's cruiser stopped teenage hitchhikers Nancy Trotter and Paula 'Sue' Wells on Florida's Treasure Coast in July 1972, Deputy Gerard Schaefer lectured them about the creeps and kidnappers out there — then kindly offered the girls a ride to Jensen Beach.

Consumed by Desire — Chad Wiersma

Consumed by Desire

When eighteen-year-old Heather Gibson tried to break up with Chad Wiersma, he drove her to a remote spot outside Kalamazoo and threatened to kill her and her family — the opening act of an obsession that would not let go.

Gay Panic — Gwen Araujo

Gay Panic

Seventeen-year-old Gwen Araujo had found the courage to live openly as a girl in California's Bay Area — but in the late summer of 2002, she began partying with a group of young men at the Merél brothers' house in Newark, where suspicion about her was growing.

Saving a Soul — Carl Eder

Saving a Soul

Devout Tom Pendergast made it his God-given mission to rescue wayward boys, so when he found six-foot-four teenage runaway Carl Eder sleeping in a coat closet at the Mission Beach Ballroom, he brought him home to his wife and children in El Cajon.

The Jacksonville Monster — Donald Smith

The Jacksonville Monster

Struggling mother Rayne Perrywinkle thought the kindly stranger offering a $150 Walmart gift card for her daughters' clothes was an answered prayer — but 'Don' was a man a Jacksonville girl had once hidden from inside a playground slide.

Dead in the Water — Oba Chandler

Dead in the Water

Jo Rogers and her daughters Michelle and Christe left their Ohio dairy farm for their first real vacation, snapping photos from a hotel room overlooking Tampa Bay — days before the Coast Guard began pulling bodies, roped to concrete blocks, from the water.

Blue Mist #22 — Robert Moorman

Blue Mist #22

On a snowy January morning in 1972, eight-year-old Shelly Mickelson climbed into her trusted neighbor Robert Moorman's Chevelle for a lunch her mother never approved — the start of a story that would end at the Blue Mist Motel in the prison town of Florence, Arizona.

The Homeschoolers — Larry and Carri Williams

The Homeschoolers

Eleven-year-old Hana Alemu was adopted from Ethiopia into Larry and Carri Williams' strict homeschooling household of nine in Sedro-Woolley, Washington — a rescue rooted in faith, and in the harsh discipline of a book called To Train Up A Child.

Divine Justice — William Cosden

Divine Justice

In a Pacific Northwest decade haunted by vanishing girls — several later confirmed as Ted Bundy victims — fourteen-year-old Kathy Devine's 1973 disappearance near Olympia sat unsolved for decades, filed under the wrong killer.

The Werewolf Butcher — Jack Spillman

The Werewolf Butcher

In September 1994, nine-year-old Penny Davis wandered off along Patterson Creek near tiny Tonasket, Washington and vanished without a trace — the beginning of a case that led to a man who believed himself a werewolf.

The Broomstick Killer — Kenneth McDuff

The Broomstick Killer

Doted on by his pistol-packing mama in tiny Rosebud, Texas, Kenneth McDuff grew from small-town bully into one of the most sinister figures in Texan history — a killer handed unprecedented leniency by the very system meant to stop him.

Bloodthirsty Parolee — Tommy Ragan

Bloodthirsty Parolee

On New Year's night 1977, thirteen-year-old Bruce Kim left a party at a run-down Centralia, Washington apartment building and never came home — a murder so obscure the author knows it only because he grew up a few blocks away.

The Incest Killer — Steven Pladl

The Incest Killer

Given up for adoption to protect her from her volatile father, Katie Fusco grew up happy in Dover, New York — until, just after turning eighteen, she went looking for her biological family and found Steven Pladl waiting.

Mom, I'm a Monster — Austin Sigg

Mom, I'm a Monster

On October 5, 2012, ten-year-old Jessica Ridgeway started her ordinary morning walk to school in Westminster, Colorado and vanished — while the man who had attacked a jogger at nearby Ketner Lake months earlier was still unidentified.

Captain Cash — Kenneth Regan

Captain Cash

London heroin dealer Ken Avery — 'Captain Cash' to the underworld — lost everything when he turned informant, so he changed his name to Ken Regan and fixed his ambitions on a wealthy Heathrow freight importer named Amarjit 'Neil' Chohan.

God Chose Us — Larry Gene Bell

God Chose Us

Two days before her high school graduation, Shari Faye Smith's little blue Chevette sat idling at the end of her family's long South Carolina driveway, the driver's door open and the mail scattered — and seventeen-year-old Shari was gone.

The Tacoma Murders — Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian

The Tacoma Murders

In 1986, months apart, young Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian were murdered near Tacoma parks just three miles from each other — crimes so similar police assumed one killer, until DNA told a stranger story that took decades to finish.

Written in Blue Ink — Alyssa Bustamante

Written in Blue Ink

Nine-year-old Elizabeth Olten set off on the four-house walk home from a neighbor's in tiny St. Martin, Missouri, and never arrived — and her cell phone signal pointed hundreds of searchers into the dark woods directly behind their homes.

The Photo Shoot — Jamie Reynolds

The Photo Shoot

Jamie Reynolds told seventeen-year-old Georgia Williams he needed a model for a 'fake hanging' photo shoot at his Wellington, England home — an art project he had carefully planned for while his parents were away in Italy.

The Green Chain Killer — Robert Napper

The Green Chain Killer

When Pauline Lasham told police her son Robert Napper had confessed to a rape near Plumstead Common, they checked their records, found nothing, and let it go — while the attacks along London's Green Chain Walk were only beginning.

A Walking Shadow — Myles Fukunaga

A Walking Shadow

Nineteen-year-old Myles Fukunaga worked eighty-hour weeks to keep his family afloat in 1929 Hawaii, but when the Hawaiian Trust Company came collecting back rent once again, his quiet desperation fixed on a plan inspired by the Leopold and Loeb case.

The Gorton Confession — James Patterson Smith

The Gorton Confession

On an April afternoon in 1996, forty-eight-year-old James Patterson Smith calmly walked into a Manchester police station to report that his teenage girlfriend, Kelly Anne Bates, had drowned in his bathtub — but the crime scene brought seasoned officers to tears.

The Toolbox Killers — Lawrence Bittaker and Roy Norris

The Toolbox Killers

Lawrence Bittaker and Roy Norris met behind prison walls, then bought a windowless 1977 GMC van they nicknamed 'Murder Mac' — and began cruising the Pacific Coast Highway toward a fire road in the San Gabriel Mountains.

The Security Chief — Chris Coleman

The Security Chief

Chris Coleman guarded world-famous televangelist Joyce Meyer for a living, yet couldn't seem to protect his own family from an anonymous letter-writer's threats — until police climbed through a window of his Columbia Lake home into a scene reeking of spray paint.

A Doctor's Blood — Dr. John Schneeberger

A Doctor's Blood

On Halloween night 1992 in tiny Kipling, Saskatchewan, a distraught young mother sought help from the town's beloved Dr. John Schneeberger — and what she remembered from that examination room would pit her word against his DNA.

Rat Alley — Mary Bell

Rat Alley

In Newcastle's crumbling Scotswood slums in 1968, four-year-old Martin Brown was found dead in a derelict house — and the trail led police to Mary Bell, a ten-year-old girl the neighborhood children already feared.

The Stolen Cradle — Michelle Bica

The Stolen Cradle

In September 2000, two expectant mothers met by chance in a Walmart and discovered they were neighbors — days later, Theresa Andrews vanished along with the Jeep Wrangler she had arranged to sell to a mystery buyer.

The Voice on the Line — David MeirhoferAudio / Video Coming Soon

The Voice on the Line

A year after a man cut a hole in the family tent at a Montana campground and took seven-year-old Susie Jaeger from among her sleeping siblings, the phone rang in the Jaeger home — and the kidnapper wanted to talk.

Reduced to Ash — Carolyn CorreaAudio / Video Coming Soon

Reduced to Ash

Ten-day-old Delimar Vera was presumed dead in a Philadelphia rowhouse fire in 1997, though no remains were ever found. Her mother, Luz Cuevas, never stopped looking at one particular child at family gatherings.

The Monster of Worcester — David McGreavyAudio / Video Coming Soon

The Monster of Worcester

In 1972, truck driver Clive Ralph and his wife Elsie trusted their lodger, David McGreavy, to babysit their three small children while Elsie worked the pub's evening shift. What happened on Gillam Street horrified all of Britain.

For You, Anna — Marianne BachmeierAudio / Video Coming Soon

For You, Anna

In Germany's medieval city of Lübeck, barmaid Marianne Bachmeier raised her daughter Anna between the tables of her pub. What Klaus Grabowski took from her — and what she did about it in a courtroom — divided a nation.

The Ordinary Boys — Craig SorgerAudio / Video Coming Soon

The Ordinary Boys

Two boys Lisa Sorger had never seen before knocked on the family trailer in Ephrata, Washington, asking if Craig could come out and play. Her autistic thirteen-year-old followed Evan Savoie and Jake Eakin into the drizzle.

Related categories

Membership

Every case, narrated.

Hundreds of true crime cases, with new cases every week. The first three minutes of every case are free, or try 5 full stories free for 3 days.

Start your 3-day free trial then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year