All cases
Try 3 days free True CrimeCase Histories Sign in
Category

Staged Scenes

In these cases the killer dressed up the crime as something else: an accident, a suicide, a burglary gone wrong or someone else’s work. Staged scenes can fool first responders, and some were accepted for months or years. What usually gives them away is a detail that does not fit, such as a wound in the wrong place, a timeline that does not work or evidence of cleaning. The stories follow the moment investigators started to doubt the first explanation and how they proved what really happened.

Cases in this category

The Poet — Ruth Finley

The Poet

For four years a stalker called the Poet terrorized Wichita secretary Ruth Finley with rhyming letters, cut phone lines and a stabbing, while police watched her house and never saw an intruder. Then one letter described the police chief’s wife.

The Vanishing Act — Elmer Crawford

The Vanishing Act

In July 1970 the Crawford family car was found at the bottom of Loch Ard Gorge with a mother and her three children inside, staged to look like a murder-suicide. Their father, Elmer Crawford, was seen at home that day and never again.

The Grieving Widow — Jennifer Faith

The Grieving Widow

Jamie Faith was walking the dog with his wife Jennifer on their quiet Dallas street when a masked gunman shot him seven times, then turned on her with duct tape. Doorbell cameras up and down South Waverly Drive caught everything.

Killing a Dead Man — Judith Cengiz

Killing a Dead Man

Lindsay Jellett, a gentle, well-loved man of forty-one, left his Ararat care home for his daily walk on a cold May evening in 1994 and never came back for dinner. What was done to him defied belief twice over.

Divorce by Homicide — Susan Wright

Divorce by Homicide

A Houston attorney handed prosecutors a card with an address on the back — and at the house on Berry Tree Drive, deputies found Jeff Wright buried beneath his own patio. His wife Susan had a story to tell.

Keep Digging — Tony Costa

Keep Digging

Pat Walsh and Mary Anne Wysocki drove to wintry Provincetown for a weekend getaway in January 1969 and never came home — and the search for them would lead into the dunes and secrets of Tony Costa's Cape Cod.

The Closing Shift — Brittany Norwood

The Closing Shift

When the manager of the Bethesda Lululemon opened up on a March morning in 2011, the store was ransacked, Jayna Murray lay dead in the back hallway — and coworker Brittany Norwood was bound on the bathroom floor, moaning.

The Lonely Hearts Killers — The Lonely Hearts Killers

The Lonely Hearts Killers

After a ship's hatch fractured his skull, Raymond Fernandez emerged a changed and dangerous man — one who trawled the lonely hearts columns and, with Martha Beck, left a trail of widows across postwar America.

Fourteen Days — The Bitter Blood Murders

Fourteen Days

Patients in Reidsville, North Carolina, trusted 'Young Dr. Klenner' with their lives — but Fritz Klenner had never attended medical school, and his years of deception would end in a trail of dead across two families.

Middle Mountain — Mark Redwine

Middle Mountain

Thirteen-year-old Dylan Redwine flew to Colorado for a court-ordered Thanksgiving visit with his father, Mark, at a remote house near Vallecito Reservoir. By morning, the boy who always texted back was gone.

The Wishing Well — Betty Lou Beets

The Wishing Well

When Jimmy Don Beets's boat was found drifting empty on Cedar Creek Lake with his heart pills on the seat, it looked like a Texas fishing tragedy. His wife, Betty Lou, knew the lake wasn't holding the answer.

The Vanishing Act — John List

The Vanishing Act

When police climbed through a window of the darkened List mansion in Westfield, New Jersey, in December 1971, the house was ice cold, the family had been 'away' for a month — and church hymns were still playing over the intercom.

The Boardwalk Murders — Kosta Fotopoulos

The Boardwalk Murders

Kosta Fotopoulos told Daytona Beach police he had shot a burglar who put a bullet in his sleeping wife's head. But the dead intruder had stolen nothing — and had walked straight to the couple's bedroom.

Goodnight, Sugar Babe — Vera Jo Reigle

Goodnight, Sugar Babe

A CSX conductor crossing a trestle bridge in Findlay, Ohio, thought the shape between the rails was a deer. It was young mother Vera Jo Reigle — and the family she trusted held the answers.

The Perfect Lie — Mark Hacking

The Perfect Lie

Mark Hacking told Salt Lake City police his wife Lori never returned from her morning jog in Memory Grove. Within weeks, investigators would uncover a web of lies so elaborate it stunned even those closest to him.

The Middletown Nightmare — Valerie Smelser

The Middletown Nightmare

Twelve-year-old Valerie Smelser vanished from a Virginia gas station restroom on a freezing January night in 1995. The story told by Norman Hoverter, the man traveling with her mother, would soon begin to unravel.

The Death Deal — Kenneth Minor

The Death Deal

Motivational speaker Jeffrey Locker was found bound behind the wheel of his station wagon in East Harlem, stabbed seven times. What led the Long Island family man to that street corner was stranger than any robbery.

The Perfect Murder — Maria Baumer

The Perfect Murder

Mushroom foragers in a Bavarian forest near Regensburg found bones fused with hardened quicklime — remains someone had tried to chemically erase. Christian F. believed he had committed the perfect murder.

The House of Secrets — Virginia McCullough

The House of Secrets

When police knocked on the door of 7 Pump Hill in Great Baddow, Essex, for a routine welfare check, Virginia McCullough had been waiting four years, three months, and twenty-eight days for that moment — and for what lay hidden behind the walls.

Silent Screams — Autumn Hallow

Silent Screams

Sarah Hallow's frantic 911 call said her stepdaughter had drowned in the bathtub — but when Elk River officers reached eight-year-old Autumn Hallow, her skin was dry, her body frail, and rigor mortis had already set in.

The Digital Trail — Benjamin Fawley

The Digital Trail

Seventeen-year-old Taylor Behl arrived at Virginia Commonwealth University brimming with excitement for college life. She had no idea that Ben Fawley — a 38-year-old 'goth' photographer whose apartment was a shrine to death — was watching her.

The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders — The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders

The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders

Best friends Jasmin and Yvonne, both sixteen, left a German discotheque at 3:00 a.m. in October 1994 and accepted a ride from a friendly middle-aged couple — a motherly woman and her quiet husband. Neither girl made it home to Limburg.

The Unraveling — Marissa DeVault

The Unraveling

To neighbors in Gilbert, Arizona, Marissa DeVault and Dale Harrell looked like a typical family — generous enough to take in a brain-injured Army veteran the kids called 'Uncle Stan.' What detectives found in the master bedroom shattered that picture.

The Stanford Cold Case — Arlis Perry

The Stanford Cold Case

'Hey, we've got a stiff in here.' Security guard Stephen Crawford's oddly detached radio call summoned police to Stanford Memorial Church at dawn in October 1974, where newlywed Arlis Perry lay dead beneath the stained glass. The hunt for her killer would span forty-four years.

The Dark Web Assassin — Stephen Allwine

The Dark Web Assassin

When Stephen Allwine calmly reported that his wife Amy had shot herself in their Cottage Grove, Minnesota home, the scene almost looked right. But the pieces didn't fit — and the trail led investigators somewhere few had ever gone: the dark web's murder-for-hire sites.

The Second Chance — Brett Morgan

The Second Chance

Louise Ellis set off from Ottawa for a weekend getaway in Quebec's Gatineau Hills in April 1995 and never arrived. Her boyfriend Brett Morgan reported her missing — after her distinctive Suzuki Sidekick turned up abandoned and locked on a rural roadside.

The Greek Pilot — Babis Anagnostopoulos

The Greek Pilot

Helicopter pilot Babis Anagnostopoulos wooed teenage Caroline Crouch on the idyllic Greek island of Alonnisos, buzzing her schoolyard to impress her. Years later, he would tell police a harrowing story about a home invasion — a story technology would put to the test.

The Pink Notebook — Tracey Richter

The Pink Notebook

Tracey Richter told the 911 dispatcher that two intruders had attacked her in her Early, Iowa home and that she had shot one to save her children. The dead man was a quiet twenty-year-old neighbor — and a pink notebook would tell a far stranger story.

A Strange Case — John Strange

A Strange Case

Firefighters dousing a blaze at an abandoned Louisville house on Memorial Day weekend 1990 found the headless body of schoolteacher Kathleen Strange in the ruins. The search for the rest of the truth ended in the last place anyone expected: her own vegetable garden.

Friendly Reminders — Erica Parsons

Friendly Reminders

No one outside the family noticed that thirteen-year-old Erica Parsons had been missing for a year and a half — until her adoptive brother Jamie, kicked out after a fierce argument, walked into the Rowan County Sheriff's Office with a chilling accusation about their parents.

It's Done — Seth Techel

It's Done

In tiny Agency, Iowa, newlywed Lisa Techel — a deputy sheriff's daughter, seventeen weeks pregnant — was killed by a shotgun blast as she slept. Her husband Seth said he was in the shower and pointed police toward the neighbor.

Web of Lies — Chandler Halderson

Web of Lies

Chandler Halderson told everyone a story: a degree nearly finished, an IT job waiting, a move to Florida planned. When his parents, Bart and Krista, went silent at their home near Madison, Wisconsin, in the summer of 2021, detectives began pulling at the threads.

The Griekwastad Farm Murders — Don Steenkamp

The Griekwastad Farm Murders

On Good Friday 2012, fifteen-year-old Don Steenkamp burst into the Griekwastad police station drenched in blood, telling officers he had found his parents and sister shot on the family farm. The question was what had really happened inside that farmhouse.

A Bad Actor — Daniel Wozniak

A Bad Actor

Struggling Orange County actor Daniel Wozniak needed money for his wedding and honeymoon. His friend and neighbor Sam Herr, an Army veteran, had $62,000 in combat-pay savings — and Wozniak had written himself a script no one saw coming.

The Frame-up — Pam Hupp

The Frame-up

Pam Hupp was the last person to see her friend Betsy Faria alive — and the newly named beneficiary of her life insurance. When Betsy's husband Russ was convicted of her murder, the story seemed over. It was only beginning.

The Suitcase Killer — Melanie McGuire

The Suitcase Killer

Bill McGuire vanished after a heated argument with his wife Melanie, a New Jersey fertility-clinic nurse, in April 2004. Then three suitcases surfaced in the Chesapeake Bay — each holding part of a grim answer.

The Creepy Uncle — Stuart Campbell

The Creepy Uncle

Fifteen-year-old Danielle Jones left for her school bus stop in East Tilbury, Essex, and vanished. Witnesses saw a girl in uniform arguing with a man in a blue van — a van that belonged to her own uncle, Stuart Campbell.

Better Off in Heaven — Laurel Schlemmer

Better Off in Heaven

To her Pittsburgh-area church and school colleagues, Laurel Schlemmer was sweet, kind-hearted, and devout — a woman who had never wanted the children her husband Mark insisted on. One morning, with their grandmother watching television downstairs, Laurel ran a bath for the boys.

The Champions — Ryan Champion

The Champions

The Champions were pillars of Cadiz, Kentucky — a farming family, an award-winning teacher, a Farm Credit director. Then police found a stranger named Vito Riservato dead at the family home, and son Ryan sitting beneath a tree in the yard, mumbling incoherently.

The Ice Cream Killer — Estibaliz Carranza

The Ice Cream Killer

Since age seven, Esti Carranza had soothed herself with vivid fantasies of killing her abusive father. Years later, she and her husband Holger opened the Schleckeria, a Vienna ice cream shop with a cellar below — and a marriage curdling behind the counter.

The Sunday School Teacher — Melissa Huckaby

The Sunday School Teacher

Eight-year-old Sandra Cantu skipped across the street outside her Tracy, California mobile home park on March 27, 2009, and was never seen again. At a community vigil, a tearful Sunday school teacher named Melissa Huckaby pressed a note into the hands of police.

Bloodstained Secrets — David Kinney

Bloodstained Secrets

The Kinney family said they discovered their best friend Brad McGarry shot dead in his basement while dropping off a weed eater in Bel-Air, Ohio. The house was ransacked, yet nothing was missing — and David Kinney's tearful account began to unravel.

The Conman — Christopher Hightower

The Conman

In September 1991, lawyer Ernest Brendel, his librarian wife Alice, and their eight-year-old daughter Emily vanished without a trace from Barrington, Rhode Island. Six weeks later, the sleepy town learned it had been living with a sociopath in its midst: Christopher Hightower.

The Swindler — Rob Petrick

The Swindler

Widowed cellist Janine Sutphen found late-life love with Rob Petrick, a churchgoing computer tinkerer she married within a year. When her devoted sons called in January 2003, Rob always had an answer: their mother was in bed, too depressed to talk.

Pretty in Pink — Ezra McCandless

Pretty in Pink

Eighteen-year-old artist Ezra McCandless fell for Jason Mengel, a National Guard medic nearly twice her age — then came Alex Woodworth, the barista they both knew from Racy's coffee shop in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. The triangle could not hold.

Rat in the Oven — Angela Stoldt

Rat in the Oven

Deltona limo driver Jimmy Sheaffer owed everyone — banks, payday lenders, bookies — so he quietly arranged for his neighbor Angela Stoldt to cash his disability checks for a hundred dollars a month. It was a favor between friends that wouldn't stay friendly.

A Cruel Hoax — Evans Ganthier

A Cruel Hoax

Rebecca Koster promised her mother she'd message when she made it home from a night out in Holbrook, Long Island. The message never came — and a single fingerprint on a strip of duct tape led police to a stranger named Evans Ganthier.

Fossil Creek — Konstantin Simberg

Fossil Creek

Konstantin Simberg arrived in Phoenix from Russia dreaming of the America he'd seen on MTV — fast cars, easy money, beautiful girls. Then he fell for Kseniya, a dancer at Christie's Cabaret, and his American dream began a dark slide toward a place called Fossil Creek.

The Cam Girl Obsession — Grant Amato

The Cam Girl Obsession

Grant Amato spent more than $2,000 a night on Silvie, a Bulgarian cam model he'd never met but called his girlfriend, inventing a life of BMWs and big houses. His real, devoted family in Chuluota, Florida had no idea what his obsession would cost them.

I Found Mom! — Leonard Tyburski

I Found Mom!

Leonard Tyburski, dean of students at Detroit's Mackenzie High School, was obsessed with order, cleanliness, and control. During a screaming argument at the bottom of the basement stairs, his wife Dorothy taunted him one time too many — beside the family's chest freezer.

Like Mother, Like Son — Cheryl Kunkle

Like Mother, Like Son

In Pennsylvania's Pocono Mountains, Cheryl Kunkle raised her son Greg Rowe on resentment and control. When sixteen-year-old Kristin Fisher refused the abortion Greg demanded and gave birth to baby Kaylee, mother and son came to share far more than a grudge.

A Heartless Mother — Ellen Boehm

A Heartless Mother

After her young son David died, St. Louis mother Ellen Boehm bought a new car rather than pay his $2,348 funeral bill — and seemed more upbeat than ever. She still held a $5,000 life insurance policy on each of her surviving children.

Her Dissociative State — Betty Frieberg

Her Dissociative State

Betty Devore carried the scars of a brutal Iowa childhood — beatings, rape, and a mother in and out of mental institutions. Three weeks after meeting charming antique dealer Harold Frieberg at a singles meeting in Fairfield, she married him. Her buried past came along.

The Dinner Theater Murder — Kimberly Hricko

The Dinner Theater Murder

Hoping to rekindle a stagnant marriage, Steven Hricko booked a Valentine's weekend at a Maryland resort featuring a murder-mystery dinner theater show. His wife Kimberly — a surgical technologist whose job included disposing of unused drugs — was suddenly, surprisingly affectionate.

Mommy's Little Helpers — Hilma Witte

Mommy's Little Helpers

Hilma Witte's Indiana household was ruled by her husband Paul's beatings — until it wasn't. Before the story ended, a grandmother lay dead in her bed, shot with a medieval crossbow as she slept, and Hilma's teenage sons carried the secrets.

A Staged Scene — Lisa Dahm Carlson

A Staged Scene

Daniel Carlson came home to the family's trailer in tiny Kapowsin, Washington, to find his wife Lisa shot to death on the couch. On the 911 call he spoke in a flat monotone, unable to recall his own address — and police found no forced entry.

Lost in the Desert — Taw Benderly

Lost in the Desert

Taw Benderly answered Loretta Bowersock's room-for-rent ad penniless and charming, and stayed for eighteen years — until December 14, 2004, when he rushed up to a Tucson mall security desk claiming Loretta had simply vanished from outside Dillard's.

Unlucky 13 — Louis Perez

Unlucky 13

On Friday the 13th of April 2012, Brittany Killgore was packing to leave Fallbrook, California when Marine Louis Perez offered a Hornblower dinner cruise in San Diego — an evening entangled with Dorothy Maraglino, a woman who despised her.

Devious Dixie — Dixie Dyson

Devious Dixie

On Halloween night 1984, accountant Mel Dyson worked late at his Huntington Beach office while his common-law wife Dixie kept to her routine — a routine that, along with two men named George Ira Lamb and Enrico Vasquez, would draw hard questions from detectives.

Mr. Mom Killer — Stephen Grant

Mr. Mom Killer

On Valentine's Day 2007, stay-at-home dad Stephen Grant walked into the Macomb County Sheriff's office to report his jet-setting executive wife Tara missing — and wept for the cameras while searchers worked nearby Stoney Creek.

The Tiger Parents — Jennifer Pan

The Tiger Parents

Hann and Bich Pan pushed their daughter Jennifer toward perfection at any cost — and when she told police three armed men had burst into the family's Toronto-area home, investigators noticed her story didn't quite add up.

The Alligator Theory — Mike Williams

The Alligator Theory

On the morning of his sixth wedding anniversary, Mike Williams set out alone to hunt ducks among the stumps of Lake Seminole and never returned — and with no body to recover, investigators reasoned the lake's alligators had left nothing to find.

Captain Cash — Kenneth Regan

Captain Cash

London heroin dealer Ken Avery — 'Captain Cash' to the underworld — lost everything when he turned informant, so he changed his name to Ken Regan and fixed his ambitions on a wealthy Heathrow freight importer named Amarjit 'Neil' Chohan.

The Oxford Murder — John Tanner

The Oxford Murder

Oxford student Rachel McLean met charming bartender John Tanner one Blackpool summer, and his stream of love letters grew as intense as his frustration with the distance — then Rachel missed an appointment she never would have missed.

The Killer Bride — Jordan Graham

The Killer Bride

Days after her Kalispell, Montana wedding, reluctant bride Jordan Graham was confiding doubts to friends — and then her new husband Cody Johnson disappeared, followed by a mysterious email claiming he had fallen from a cliff in Glacier National Park.

The Dexter Wannabe — Mark Twitchell

The Dexter Wannabe

A first date arranged on plentyoffish.com came with strange instructions — sneak in under the half-open garage door — and Gilles Tetreault stumbled out of that dark garage having barely escaped a man in a hockey mask following a script.

The Repo Man — Mike Adams

The Repo Man

Repo man Mike Adams kept his Frisco, Texas showplace in flawless order — labels facing forward, a couch no one could sit on, handguns sorted by caliber — and his fixations turned menacing after Nicole Leger and her teenage son moved in.

The Burning Barrel — Fred Grabbe

The Burning Barrel

On a July evening in 1981, Charlotte Grabbe never came back from the soybean fields of her family's Marshall, Illinois farm — her tractor parked in the shed, her lunch box untouched, and her divorce from the violent Fred Grabbe still unfinished.

Master and Slave — Graham Dwyer

Master and Slave

Elaine O'Hara vanished near Dublin in August 2012, the day after her release from a psychiatric hospital — and the investigation that unfolded over the next three years exposed one of the most shocking crimes in Irish history.

The Security Chief — Chris Coleman

The Security Chief

Chris Coleman guarded world-famous televangelist Joyce Meyer for a living, yet couldn't seem to protect his own family from an anonymous letter-writer's threats — until police climbed through a window of his Columbia Lake home into a scene reeking of spray paint.

Related categories

Membership

Every case, narrated.

Hundreds of true crime cases, with new cases every week. The first three minutes of every case are free, or try 5 full stories free for 3 days.

Start your 3-day free trial then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year