All cases
Try 3 days free True CrimeCase Histories Sign in
Category

Missing Persons

These cases began with someone who disappeared. Some were later found to have been murdered, some were never found at all, and some turned out to be very different stories from the ones police first assumed. Missing-person cases are hard to investigate because there is often no crime scene, no body and no clear moment when something went wrong. The stories follow the families who kept searching, the detectives who reopened the files and the evidence that finally explained what happened, where it ever was explained.

Cases in this category

The Sleepover — Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman

The Sleepover

Ashley Freeman turned sixteen on December 29, 1999, and her best friend Lauria Bible stayed over at the family trailer near Welch, Oklahoma. Before dawn the trailer was in flames, and the two girls were gone.

Keep Digging — Tony Costa

Keep Digging

Pat Walsh and Mary Anne Wysocki drove to wintry Provincetown for a weekend getaway in January 1969 and never came home — and the search for them would lead into the dunes and secrets of Tony Costa's Cape Cod.

The Speed Freaks — The Speed Freak Killers

The Speed Freaks

Wesley Shermantine and Loren Herzog grew up inseparable across Fine Road in tiny Linden, California. What the two friends did in the methamphetamine years would leave San Joaquin County digging for victims decades later.

Middle Mountain — Mark Redwine

Middle Mountain

Thirteen-year-old Dylan Redwine flew to Colorado for a court-ordered Thanksgiving visit with his father, Mark, at a remote house near Vallecito Reservoir. By morning, the boy who always texted back was gone.

The Wishing Well — Betty Lou Beets

The Wishing Well

When Jimmy Don Beets's boat was found drifting empty on Cedar Creek Lake with his heart pills on the seat, it looked like a Texas fishing tragedy. His wife, Betty Lou, knew the lake wasn't holding the answer.

The Killing Cousins — The Killing Cousins

The Killing Cousins

Fifteen-year-old Michael Rock was riding his bike past a Vero Beach house in July 1983 when a naked, bound teenage girl came running down the gravel driveway, screaming — with a large man in pursuit.

The Lakewood Monster — Guy Rasmussen

The Lakewood Monster

On the Fourth of July 1996, nine-year-old Cynthia Allinger left her Lakewood, Washington, apartment in her favorite flowered dress to visit friends nearby. By the time the fireworks faded, she still hadn't come home.

The Perfect Lie — Mark Hacking

The Perfect Lie

Mark Hacking told Salt Lake City police his wife Lori never returned from her morning jog in Memory Grove. Within weeks, investigators would uncover a web of lies so elaborate it stunned even those closest to him.

The Perfect Murder — Maria Baumer

The Perfect Murder

Mushroom foragers in a Bavarian forest near Regensburg found bones fused with hardened quicklime — remains someone had tried to chemically erase. Christian F. believed he had committed the perfect murder.

The Cleveland Monster — Ariel Castro

The Cleveland Monster

Michelle Knight was rushing to a custody hearing in 2002 when a familiar Cleveland school bus driver named Ariel Castro offered her a ride — with a quick stop at his ordinary-looking house on Seymour Avenue.

The Digital Trail — Benjamin Fawley

The Digital Trail

Seventeen-year-old Taylor Behl arrived at Virginia Commonwealth University brimming with excitement for college life. She had no idea that Ben Fawley — a 38-year-old 'goth' photographer whose apartment was a shrine to death — was watching her.

The Smooth Talker — Roy Melanson

The Smooth Talker

On a July night in 1974, a charming stranger lingered at the bar of Fagiani's Cocktail Lounge in Napa as Anita Andrews closed up alone. It would take decades to learn who the smooth talker really was.

The Animal — Jerry Walter McFadden

The Animal

In July 1979, Rose Hlavka came home to a silent Portland apartment and found her twenty-year-old sister Anna Marie strangled with a clock radio cord — a crime so cold it would wait decades for an answer.

The Crown Hill Murder — Nathan Matthews

The Crown Hill Murder

Sixteen-year-old Becky Watts was home alone in Bristol's Crown Hill neighborhood on an ordinary Thursday in February 2015. By evening she had vanished — and the search would lead somewhere her family never imagined.

The Viking Princess — Tanner Horner

The Viking Princess

Seven-year-old Athena Strand, who dreamed of being a Viking princess in pink armor, hopped off the school bus near her home in Paradise, Texas, in November 2022. By nightfall she was missing — and the search led to a delivery driver named Tanner Horner.

Blue Earth Jane Doe — Robert Leroy Nelson

Blue Earth Jane Doe

Michelle Busha fled her strict Bay City, Texas home and called her family from the road — until the calls stopped in the spring of 1980. That May, a young woman found murdered near Blue Earth, Minnesota, was buried without a name, a Jane Doe for decades.

The Reno Predator — James Biela

The Reno Predator

Nineteen-year-old Brianna Denison fell asleep on a friend's couch near the University of Nevada, Reno campus in January 2008, a teddy bear tucked under her head. By morning she was gone — and police realized a predator had been stalking the university district for months.

Fox Hollow Farm — Herb Baumeister

Fox Hollow Farm

Exploring the woods behind his family's eighteen-acre Indiana estate in 1994, thirteen-year-old Erich Baumeister carried a human skull back to the house. His father Herb had an explanation — one that would hold for two more years.

The Waterbed — Joshua Phillips

The Waterbed

Eight-year-old Maddie Clifton finished her piano practice and went out to play in her Jacksonville neighborhood on November 3, 1998, then vanished. For days, hundreds searched — while the answer lay closer to home than anyone could bear to imagine.

The Second Chance — Brett Morgan

The Second Chance

Louise Ellis set off from Ottawa for a weekend getaway in Quebec's Gatineau Hills in April 1995 and never arrived. Her boyfriend Brett Morgan reported her missing — after her distinctive Suzuki Sidekick turned up abandoned and locked on a rural roadside.

Count to Three — Skylar Neese

Count to Three

A security camera caught sixteen-year-old Skylar Neese slipping out her bedroom window at 12:30 a.m. and climbing into a waiting car in Star City, West Virginia. She knew the people inside — which made what happened next all the more incomprehensible.

The Night Shift — Donald Blom

The Night Shift

Nineteen-year-old Katie Poirier was working the late shift alone at D.J.'s Expressway Conoco in Moose Lake, Minnesota, in the spring of 1999 when a man walked in before closing. A grainy security tape captured what happened next — and launched a desperate search.

Friendly Reminders — Erica Parsons

Friendly Reminders

No one outside the family noticed that thirteen-year-old Erica Parsons had been missing for a year and a half — until her adoptive brother Jamie, kicked out after a fierce argument, walked into the Rowan County Sheriff's Office with a chilling accusation about their parents.

The Highway of Tears — Cody Legebokoff

The Highway of Tears

On a snowy November night in 2010, an RCMP officer watched a black pickup fishtail out of a deserted logging road near British Columbia's infamous Highway of Tears. The young driver, Cody Legebokoff, had blood on his face — and a story that didn't add up.

The Christadelphian — Gary Schaefer

The Christadelphian

Springfield, Vermont, seemed like a postcard New England town until thirteen-year-old Sherry Nastasia vanished in August 1979. Over the next four years more young girls were taken — and the clue that finally broke the case was a church sweatshirt.

No Body, No Crime — Kimberly Kessler

No Body, No Crime

On Mother's Day 2018, hairstylist Joleen Cummings failed to pick up her three children in Yulee, Florida. Suspicion fell on a coworker at Tangles Hair Salon — a woman who, it turned out, had lived under eighteen different names across fourteen states.

The Frankston Serial Killer — Paul Denyer

The Frankston Serial Killer

In the winter of 1993, the seaside Melbourne suburb of Frankston lived in terror as three young women — a student, a new mother out buying milk, a girl taking a shortcut home — were murdered in a matter of weeks. A yellow Toyota spotted near a bike path changed everything.

The Mission Valley Mall Murders — Carlo Mercado

The Mission Valley Mall Murders

Days before Christmas 2013, Ilona Flint and Salvatore Belvedere were shot in a San Diego mall parking lot while searching for Salvatore's missing brother Gianni — Ilona's fiancé. Three weeks later, Gianni's car turned up a hundred miles away with a terrible secret in the trunk.

The Sacrificial Shack — Adolfo Constanzo

The Sacrificial Shack

Pre-med student Mark Kilroy and three childhood friends made their third annual spring-break trip to South Padre Island in March 1989. One night across the border in Matamoros, Mark stepped away from his friends — and vanished into something far darker than anyone imagined.

Web of Lies — Chandler Halderson

Web of Lies

Chandler Halderson told everyone a story: a degree nearly finished, an IT job waiting, a move to Florida planned. When his parents, Bart and Krista, went silent at their home near Madison, Wisconsin, in the summer of 2021, detectives began pulling at the threads.

Gone in Three Minutes — Christina Morris

Gone in Three Minutes

Surveillance cameras in Plano, Texas, captured Christina Morris walking into a parking garage with acquaintance Enrique Arochi just before 4:00 a.m. Minutes later, only his car emerged — and Christina was never seen again.

An Easy Target — Edwin Hall

An Easy Target

Eighteen-year-old Kelsey Smith dashed into a Target in Overland Park, Kansas, on June 2, 2007, to grab a last-minute anniversary gift for her boyfriend. Store cameras recorded her leaving — and what happened in the seconds after she reached her car.

Room 308 — Jesse Kempson

Room 308

Twenty-one-year-old British backpacker Grace Millane was partway through her round-the-world gap year when she matched with a man named Jesse on Tinder in Auckland. On December 1, 2018, she agreed to meet him for drinks — and was never seen again.

The City Planner — Robert Anthony Buell

The City Planner

Twelve-year-old Tina Marie Harmon stopped for a fudgesicle in Creston, Ohio, and never caught up with her friends. Two men were charged in her death — while matching orange carpet fibers kept turning up wherever more young girls were found.

Death of a Cheerleader — Charles Rathbun

Death of a Cheerleader

Model and former Raiderette Linda Sobek changed her answering machine on November 16, 1995, saying she would be on location all day for a photo shoot. She never returned to hear her messages — and attention turned to photographer Charles Rathbun.

Collateral Damage — Douglas Garland

Collateral Damage

Five-year-old Nathan O'Brien begged to sleep over at his grandparents' Calgary home the night of their estate sale in June 2014. When his mother returned the next morning, Nathan, Alvin, and Kathy Liknes were gone — and the house told a grim story.

The Hitchhiker Slayer — Thor Christiansen

The Hitchhiker Slayer

In 1970s Isla Vista, hitchhiking was simply how UC Santa Barbara students got around — until young women with outstretched thumbs began to vanish. When Jacqueline Rook missed Thanksgiving with her family, the community's free-spirited trust began to crumble.

The Leaf Killer — Matthew Hoffman

The Leaf Killer

When Tina Herrmann missed her shift at the Mount Vernon Dairy Queen, her manager drove out to check on her — and found a house full of blood but no trace of Tina, her two children, or her friend Stephanie Sprang.

Creepy White Van — Travis Forbes

Creepy White Van

Nineteen-year-old Kenia Monge planned to meet friends at a Denver nightclub called Lavish on a warm March night in 2011. She never made it inside — and suspicion soon fell on a stranger with a white van who had offered her a ride.

The Creepy Uncle — Stuart Campbell

The Creepy Uncle

Fifteen-year-old Danielle Jones left for her school bus stop in East Tilbury, Essex, and vanished. Witnesses saw a girl in uniform arguing with a man in a blue van — a van that belonged to her own uncle, Stuart Campbell.

Folly Beach — Richard Valenti

Folly Beach

In May 1973, fourteen-year-old Alexis Latimer and her best friend Sherri Clark took one last stroll down Folly Beach before dark. Police insisted the girls had run off with boys — until more young women were attacked in the sleepy South Carolina beach town.

Mr. Big — Brett Peter Cowan

Mr. Big

Thirteen-year-old Daniel Morcombe stood beneath a Queensland overpass in December 2003, waiting for a bus that had broken down. When the next bus arrived ten minutes later, Daniel — and the man seen lingering behind him — had vanished.

The River Brent Killer — Alice Gross

The River Brent Killer

On a warm August afternoon in 2014, fourteen-year-old Alice Gross texted her father that she was heading home along West London's canal towpath. Dinner came and went, and Alice never arrived — and the search would lead police to a Latvian immigrant with a dark past.

The Crossword Murder — Lars Bense

The Crossword Murder

Seven-year-old Lars Bense set off through the snow to meet friends at the cinema in Halle-Neustadt, East Germany — a planned city of numbered concrete blocks with no street names. He vanished in the final few hundred feet, and the strangest clue would be a crossword puzzle.

The Groomer — Kayleigh Haywood

The Groomer

'Hi, how are you? I've seen your picture. You're very pretty.' The Facebook message that reached fifteen-year-old Kayleigh Haywood on Halloween 2015 came from twenty-seven-year-old Luke Harlow — and thirteen days of hidden messages convinced her she was loved.

The Screwdriver Killer — George Davies

The Screwdriver Killer

In 1957, Connecticut's George Davies answered a newspaper ad — 'French girl desires light housekeeping' — with devious intentions. Seventeen-year-old Gaetane Boivin left a note about a job opportunity and never came home; days later, nine-year-old Brenda Jane Doucette vanished walking to school.

Death in the Cornfield — James Worley

Death in the Cornfield

Sierah Joughin pedaled her purple bicycle home through the cornfields outside Metamora, Ohio, after a lazy July afternoon with her boyfriend Josh, promising to call him that night. By 9:30, her bedroom light was on — but Sierah was nowhere to be found.

The Fifth Nail — Joseph Edward Duncan III

The Fifth Nail

A Wolf Lodge, Idaho, man called 911 about a strange white truck on his property; hours later he called back, frantic, after finding blood smeared on his neighbors' door. Inside the Groene home, deputies found bodies bound with duct tape — and the youngest children gone.

Tony the Pervert — Shaun “Tony” Armstrong

Tony the Pervert

Three-year-old Rosie Palmer bought an ice pop from the ice cream van outside her Hartlepool, England home and vanished within the hour. Police went door to door; a few houses away, Shaun 'Tony' Armstrong told them he hadn't seen her, and they moved on.

Missing in Mississippi — Annie Laurie Hearin

Missing in Mississippi

Annie Laurie Hearin, wife of one of Mississippi's wealthiest men, vanished from her Jackson mansion one Tuesday afternoon in 1988 — leaving behind her shoes, purse, car, and the medication she couldn't survive without. A ransom note pointed to twelve names.

The Sunday School Teacher — Melissa Huckaby

The Sunday School Teacher

Eight-year-old Sandra Cantu skipped across the street outside her Tracy, California mobile home park on March 27, 2009, and was never seen again. At a community vigil, a tearful Sunday school teacher named Melissa Huckaby pressed a note into the hands of police.

The Leg Thing — Joe Clark

The Leg Thing

Fourteen-year-old Chris Steiner vanished from his Baraboo, Wisconsin home on the night of July 4, 1994, leaving a window screen cut from the outside and muddy footprints on the carpet. A year later, thirteen-year-old Thad Phillips woke to find himself being carried into the dark.

Vanished Innocence — Mona Rae Minyard

Vanished Innocence

Two days after Christmas 1962, six-year-old Mona Rae Minyard walked to Portland's Three Brothers Market with a five-dollar bill and her mother's short grocery list. She never came home — and suspicion settled on Joseph Walton Holmes, the man who lived just across the field.

A Sad Holiday Season — John Taylor

A Sad Holiday Season

Sixteen-year-old Leanne Tiernan said goodbye to her best friend after a day of Christmas shopping in Leeds and took the unlit shortcut through Houghley Gill. Police searched 1,400 houses, drained three miles of canals, and questioned 140 men — and found no trace of her.

The Christmas Tree Farm Murders — Ricky Riffe

The Christmas Tree Farm Murders

Ed and Minnie Maurin, in their eighties and famous for the Christmas luncheon at their Ethel, Washington tree-farm home, were missing when friends arrived to set up the 1985 party. Inside the locked house, bank statements lay scattered across the bathroom floor.

The Girl Scout — David Westerfield

The Girl Scout

Selling Girl Scout cookies door to door in Sabre Springs, California, Brenda van Dam and seven-year-old Danielle stopped at the immaculate home of wealthy neighbor David Westerfield — who bought cookies, showed off his kitchen, and mentioned his 'adult parties.' That weekend, Danielle vanished.

Wheres Savanna — Savanna LaFontaine-Greywind

Wheres Savanna

Nursing student Savanna Greywind, twenty-two and pregnant, lived with her close-knit family in a Fargo apartment building where neighbors rarely got past hello in the hallway. Then the woman from the third floor knocked on the Greywinds' door — and Savanna answered.

The Bushy-Haired Stranger — Frank Jarvis Atwood

The Bushy-Haired Stranger

Eight-year-old Vicki Lynne Hoskinson pedaled her pink Christmas bicycle two blocks to mail a birthday card in Tucson, Arizona, in September 1984. Minutes later, her sister found the bike lying in the middle of the road — and no sign of Vicki.

The Conman — Christopher Hightower

The Conman

In September 1991, lawyer Ernest Brendel, his librarian wife Alice, and their eight-year-old daughter Emily vanished without a trace from Barrington, Rhode Island. Six weeks later, the sleepy town learned it had been living with a sociopath in its midst: Christopher Hightower.

The Swindler — Rob Petrick

The Swindler

Widowed cellist Janine Sutphen found late-life love with Rob Petrick, a churchgoing computer tinkerer she married within a year. When her devoted sons called in January 2003, Rob always had an answer: their mother was in bed, too depressed to talk.

The Murder of Stephanie Hebert — Stephanie Hebert

The Murder of Stephanie Hebert

Five-year-old Stephanie Hebert set off for a friend's house three doors down Aster Lane in Waggaman, Louisiana, in June 1978 — and never made it. More than 150 deputies searched the canals and levees for the little girl in baby-blue glasses without finding a trace.

The Eagle Scout — John Joubert

The Eagle Scout

Thirteen-year-old paperboy Danny Joe Eberle vanished from his Bellevue, Nebraska route one Sunday morning in 1983, leaving behind his beloved BMX bike and a bag of undelivered newspapers. Just thirteen days earlier, another paperboy had disappeared two hours away in Des Moines.

Pied Piper of Tucson — Charles Schmid

Pied Piper of Tucson

Charles 'Smitty' Schmid stuffed his cowboy boots with crushed cans, wore pancake makeup, and painted on a fake mole — and Tucson's teenagers followed him anyway. Then he told Mary French he wanted to know what killing felt like, and asked her to pick the girl.

Rat in the Oven — Angela Stoldt

Rat in the Oven

Deltona limo driver Jimmy Sheaffer owed everyone — banks, payday lenders, bookies — so he quietly arranged for his neighbor Angela Stoldt to cash his disability checks for a hundred dollars a month. It was a favor between friends that wouldn't stay friendly.

A Tragic December — Vincent Tabak

A Tragic December

On a snowy December Friday in 2010, Joanna Yeates kissed her boyfriend goodbye at the Bristol train station, had drinks with coworkers, and bought a pizza for her first night alone in their basement flat. She never answered another of his calls.

The Count — Edmund Arne Matthews

The Count

Eighteen-year-old Lisa Mather spent a 1985 Saturday night dancing outside the clubs of the Sunset Strip. When police scattered the underage crowd, her friends lost her — she was last seen talking to a tall, skinny boy dressed all in black with teased 'rocker hair.'

Angelic — Daniel Holdom

Angelic

In 2008, Karlie Pearce-Stevenson left remote Alice Springs with her toddler, Khandalyce, and a boyfriend fifteen years her senior, Daniel Holdom. A year later her calls and texts home stopped — though her bank account stayed strangely active.

A Cruel Hoax — Evans Ganthier

A Cruel Hoax

Rebecca Koster promised her mother she'd message when she made it home from a night out in Holbrook, Long Island. The message never came — and a single fingerprint on a strip of duct tape led police to a stranger named Evans Ganthier.

The Piggy Palace — Robert Pickton

The Piggy Palace

Women had been vanishing from Vancouver's Downtown Eastside since 1983 — so many, and so invisible, that authorities took nearly a decade to notice. The trail eventually led out of the city to a pig farm and a man named Robert 'Willy' Pickton.

Where is Heather? — Heather Teague

Where is Heather?

Peering through his new high-powered telescope over the Ohio River, Tim Walthall watched a young woman set up her beach chair on the Kentucky shore — then witnessed something that sent him racing for the phone. The search for Heather Teague never truly ended.

The Alligator Man — Joe Ball

The Alligator Man

Joe Ball — bootlegger, brawler, crack shot — ran the Sociable Inn off Highway 181 in tiny Elmendorf, Texas, a rowdy roadhouse with poker tables, cold beer, and a pit of live alligators. Then people around Joe started to disappear.

Limb From Limb — Jared Chance

Limb From Limb

Ashley Young was compassionate to a fault and believed in second chances. That generosity led her to Jared Chance — a bully with thirty-eight brushes with the law in his first ten years of adulthood, and the man the author says would destroy her.

I Found Mom! — Leonard Tyburski

I Found Mom!

Leonard Tyburski, dean of students at Detroit's Mackenzie High School, was obsessed with order, cleanliness, and control. During a screaming argument at the bottom of the basement stairs, his wife Dorothy taunted him one time too many — beside the family's chest freezer.

The Family Murders — Bevan Spencer von Einem

The Family Murders

In 1972, Bevan Spencer von Einem was hailed a hero for rescuing two men thrown into Adelaide's River Torrens. Seven years later, sixteen-year-old Alan Barnes stuck out his thumb on Grand Junction Road to hitch a ride home — and never arrived.

The Llama Farm Murder — Sky McDonough

The Llama Farm Murder

Seventeen-year-old Leanna Walker told friends she planned to run away with Sky McDonough, a self-styled Rastafarian who quoted Bible verses about killing a wife who leaves. When she vanished from Milford, Pennsylvania, the search closed in on the woods around a llama farm.

Lost in the Desert — Taw Benderly

Lost in the Desert

Taw Benderly answered Loretta Bowersock's room-for-rent ad penniless and charming, and stayed for eighteen years — until December 14, 2004, when he rushed up to a Tucson mall security desk claiming Loretta had simply vanished from outside Dillard's.

The Crybaby Killer — Kenneth Biros

The Crybaby Killer

Feeling ill, bartender Tami Engstrom left her shift early and stopped at the Nickelodeon Lounge in Masury, Ohio, where she showed off her new diamond ring and drank into the night with her uncle's friend, Kenneth Biros — and never made it home.

The Darlington Cannibal — David Harker

The Darlington Cannibal

When Julie Paterson vanished after a trip to a Darlington pub in April 1998, her boyfriend Alan knew she would never miss a visit with her daughter — and weeks later, a police dog led its handler into the overgrown garden of a house that wasn't abandoned after all.

The Submarine Case — Peter Madsen

The Submarine Case

Journalist Kim Wall skipped her own going-away party for a two-hour ride on inventor 'Rocket' Peter Madsen's homemade submarine, the UC3 Nautilus — and by the next day the sub was at the bottom of Copenhagen harbor and Madsen's story was already shifting.

Cold Storage Killer — John Famalaro

Cold Storage Killer

After a Morrissey concert in June 1991, Denise Huber's gray Honda Accord was found abandoned on the Corona del Mar highway with a flat rear tire, just miles from her Newport Beach home — and for three years there was no trace of her at all.

The Werewolf Butcher — Jack Spillman

The Werewolf Butcher

In September 1994, nine-year-old Penny Davis wandered off along Patterson Creek near tiny Tonasket, Washington and vanished without a trace — the beginning of a case that led to a man who believed himself a werewolf.

The Broomstick Killer — Kenneth McDuff

The Broomstick Killer

Doted on by his pistol-packing mama in tiny Rosebud, Texas, Kenneth McDuff grew from small-town bully into one of the most sinister figures in Texan history — a killer handed unprecedented leniency by the very system meant to stop him.

Bloodthirsty Parolee — Tommy Ragan

Bloodthirsty Parolee

On New Year's night 1977, thirteen-year-old Bruce Kim left a party at a run-down Centralia, Washington apartment building and never came home — a murder so obscure the author knows it only because he grew up a few blocks away.

The Body in the Bag — Will Matheson

The Body in the Bag

Will Matheson grew up in a chaotic Sydney hoarder house shadowed by tragedy and developed a deep fixation with death — years before anyone thought to look inside the oversized cricket bag that was far too heavy to lift.

Mr. Mom Killer — Stephen Grant

Mr. Mom Killer

On Valentine's Day 2007, stay-at-home dad Stephen Grant walked into the Macomb County Sheriff's office to report his jet-setting executive wife Tara missing — and wept for the cameras while searchers worked nearby Stoney Creek.

Mom, I'm a Monster — Austin Sigg

Mom, I'm a Monster

On October 5, 2012, ten-year-old Jessica Ridgeway started her ordinary morning walk to school in Westminster, Colorado and vanished — while the man who had attacked a jogger at nearby Ketner Lake months earlier was still unidentified.

The Alligator Theory — Mike Williams

The Alligator Theory

On the morning of his sixth wedding anniversary, Mike Williams set out alone to hunt ducks among the stumps of Lake Seminole and never returned — and with no body to recover, investigators reasoned the lake's alligators had left nothing to find.

The Kičevo Monster — Vlado Taneski

The Kičevo Monster

In sleepy Kičevo, Macedonia, three older women were beaten and strangled between 2005 and 2008 — and mild-mannered local journalist Vlado Taneski covered the murders with an uncanny eye for details no reporter should have known.

Captain Cash — Kenneth Regan

Captain Cash

London heroin dealer Ken Avery — 'Captain Cash' to the underworld — lost everything when he turned informant, so he changed his name to Ken Regan and fixed his ambitions on a wealthy Heathrow freight importer named Amarjit 'Neil' Chohan.

The Oxford Murder — John Tanner

The Oxford Murder

Oxford student Rachel McLean met charming bartender John Tanner one Blackpool summer, and his stream of love letters grew as intense as his frustration with the distance — then Rachel missed an appointment she never would have missed.

God Chose Us — Larry Gene Bell

God Chose Us

Two days before her high school graduation, Shari Faye Smith's little blue Chevette sat idling at the end of her family's long South Carolina driveway, the driver's door open and the mail scattered — and seventeen-year-old Shari was gone.

A Unicorn Among Beasts — Steven Capobianco

A Unicorn Among Beasts

On Maui's laid-back North Shore, red-haired Charli Scott called herself 'a unicorn among beasts' — until the night she drove out past Ke'anae to help her ex-boyfriend Steven Capobianco with his stalled truck and never came home.

The Canal Killer — John Sweeney

The Canal Killer

In February 2001, two boys fishing in London's Regent's Canal snagged a duffel bag weighted with bricks — the first of six bags divers would recover, holding a woman whose missing head, hands, and feet made her nearly impossible to identify.

Arizona Torso Murder #2 — Marjorie Orbin

Arizona Torso Murder #2

Six-times-married showgirl Marjorie Orbin finally landed the comfortable Scottsdale life with art dealer Jay Orbin — then Jay vanished on the road, and a blue Rubbermaid container turned up at the edge of the desert.

The Tacoma Murders — Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian

The Tacoma Murders

In 1986, months apart, young Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian were murdered near Tacoma parks just three miles from each other — crimes so similar police assumed one killer, until DNA told a stranger story that took decades to finish.

The Killer Bride — Jordan Graham

The Killer Bride

Days after her Kalispell, Montana wedding, reluctant bride Jordan Graham was confiding doubts to friends — and then her new husband Cody Johnson disappeared, followed by a mysterious email claiming he had fallen from a cliff in Glacier National Park.

The Girl in the Barrel — Howard Elkins

The Girl in the Barrel

During a final walkthrough before the sale of a Jericho, New York house in September 1999, the buyer insisted on removing a 355-pound barrel that had sat wedged in the crawlspace for decades — a barrel the seller had never once opened.

No Body, No Doubt — Bryan Stewart

No Body, No Doubt

When Jamie Laiaddee disappeared from Arizona, prosecutor Juan Martinez — later famous for the Jodi Arias trial — took her boyfriend to court without a body, without physical evidence, and with a defendant who answered to two different names.

The Dexter Wannabe — Mark Twitchell

The Dexter Wannabe

A first date arranged on plentyoffish.com came with strange instructions — sneak in under the half-open garage door — and Gilles Tetreault stumbled out of that dark garage having barely escaped a man in a hockey mask following a script.

Written in Blue Ink — Alyssa Bustamante

Written in Blue Ink

Nine-year-old Elizabeth Olten set off on the four-house walk home from a neighbor's in tiny St. Martin, Missouri, and never arrived — and her cell phone signal pointed hundreds of searchers into the dark woods directly behind their homes.

Models Inc. — Lester Jones

Models Inc.

On June 28, 2007, Paige Birgfeld drove home from a picnic with her high-school-sweetheart ex-husband and vanished — and the search for the Grand Junction, Colorado mother of three uncovered a secret life no one around her suspected.

The Photo Shoot — Jamie Reynolds

The Photo Shoot

Jamie Reynolds told seventeen-year-old Georgia Williams he needed a model for a 'fake hanging' photo shoot at his Wellington, England home — an art project he had carefully planned for while his parents were away in Italy.

The Girl in the Box — Cameron Hooker

The Girl in the Box

In 1977, twenty-year-old hitchhiker Colleen Stan turned down rides that looked like trouble before accepting one from a clean-cut young couple with a baby — a decision near Red Bluff, California that would swallow seven years of her life.

A Walking Shadow — Myles Fukunaga

A Walking Shadow

Nineteen-year-old Myles Fukunaga worked eighty-hour weeks to keep his family afloat in 1929 Hawaii, but when the Hawaiian Trust Company came collecting back rent once again, his quiet desperation fixed on a plan inspired by the Leopold and Loeb case.

The Burning Barrel — Fred Grabbe

The Burning Barrel

On a July evening in 1981, Charlotte Grabbe never came back from the soybean fields of her family's Marshall, Illinois farm — her tractor parked in the shed, her lunch box untouched, and her divorce from the violent Fred Grabbe still unfinished.

Master and Slave — Graham Dwyer

Master and Slave

Elaine O'Hara vanished near Dublin in August 2012, the day after her release from a psychiatric hospital — and the investigation that unfolded over the next three years exposed one of the most shocking crimes in Irish history.

The Stolen Cradle — Michelle Bica

The Stolen Cradle

In September 2000, two expectant mothers met by chance in a Walmart and discovered they were neighbors — days later, Theresa Andrews vanished along with the Jeep Wrangler she had arranged to sell to a mystery buyer.

What the Garden Knew — Gerard Baden-ClayAudio / Video Coming Soon

What the Garden Knew

Allison Baden-Clay spoke six languages, raised three daughters, and was married to a Brisbane real estate agent carrying the famous Baden-Powell name. When she vanished from their Brookfield home in 2012, the garden held the first clue.

The Kiss of Death — Jeffrey WillisAudio / Video Coming Soon

The Kiss of Death

Jessica Heeringa was closing the Norton Shores Exxon alone on an April night in 2013 when a silver minivan backed up to the rear door, headlights off. The station had no security cameras — and Jessica was never seen again.

What the Woods Kept — Marcus SanfratelloAudio / Video Coming Soon

What the Woods Kept

Terry Peroni was last seen walking into the Oregon woods with Marcus Sanfratello after a Fourth of July party in 1983. What searchers eventually found along the Illinois River kept the case alive for forty years.

The Shadow Brother — Cary StaynerAudio / Video Coming Soon

The Shadow Brother

Carole Sund planned every detail of her February 1999 trip to Yosemite with daughter Juli and Argentine exchange student Silvina Pelosso. When the three vanished with their rented red Pontiac, the search led to a man no one suspected.

California — Alissa TurneyAudio / Video Coming Soon

California

Seventeen-year-old Alissa Turney had $1,800 saved for a summer in California when she disappeared from Phoenix on the last day of her junior year — leaving behind her stepfather, a former sheriff's deputy, and questions that lasted decades.

2-4-1 — Jesse Leroy Matthew Jr.Audio / Video Coming Soon

2-4-1

Virginia Tech junior Morgan Harrington left her seat at a Metallica concert in Charlottesville in 2009 and never came back inside — and years later the case of Hannah Graham would bring her name roaring back.

Related categories

Membership

Every case, narrated.

Hundreds of true crime cases, with new cases every week. The first three minutes of every case are free, or try 5 full stories free for 3 days.

Start your 3-day free trial then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year