In these cases no one has been convicted and the answer is still out there. Some have a strong suspect who was never charged or who died before trial; others have no suspect at all. The stories lay out what is known: the timeline, the evidence, the theories investigators pursued and why each fell short. Several of these cases remain open, with rewards still offered and police still asking for information. They are told as fairly as possible, without naming anyone as guilty who has not been proven so.

For years, Ken McElroy terrorized the tiny farming town of Skidmore, Missouri, shrugging off charge after charge. Then, in broad daylight on the town's main street, someone shot the bully — in front of dozens of witnesses who all claimed to have seen nothing.

Bill Mowbray was Brownsville's flamboyant Cadillac king — lakeside mansion, beach condos, his face on TV commercials — and secretly drowning in debt. When a gunshot rang out in the couple's bedroom, the answer to what happened would hinge on chemical traces of blood.

Two days after Christmas 1962, six-year-old Mona Rae Minyard walked to Portland's Three Brothers Market with a five-dollar bill and her mother's short grocery list. She never came home — and suspicion settled on Joseph Walton Holmes, the man who lived just across the field.

Five-year-old Stephanie Hebert set off for a friend's house three doors down Aster Lane in Waggaman, Louisiana, in June 1978 — and never made it. More than 150 deputies searched the canals and levees for the little girl in baby-blue glasses without finding a trace.

Peering through his new high-powered telescope over the Ohio River, Tim Walthall watched a young woman set up her beach chair on the Kentucky shore — then witnessed something that sent him racing for the phone. The search for Heather Teague never truly ended.

Ted Binion, heir to the Horseshoe casino fortune, buried millions in silver in a desert vault near Pahrump, Nevada — and only two people had the security codes: Binion himself and his young girlfriend's new friend, Rick Tabish.

Teenage prodigy Candace Hiltz was bound for Stanford Law when she was found shot dead in her family's remote Copper Gulch, Colorado home — a still-unsolved case that took a strange turn when a delinquent storage unit went up for auction.

For two years a predator the papers called the Beast of Buckland stalked the women of Portsmouth after dark. Then 24-year-old barmaid Linda Cook took the short way home — and police fixed on the wrong man.
No cases tagged this yet.
Back to all casesHundreds of true crime cases, with new cases every week. The first three minutes of every case are free, or try 5 full stories free for 3 days.
Start your 3-day free trial then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year