All cases
Try 3 days free True CrimeCase Histories Sign in
Category

Cold Cases

These are investigations that went quiet for years, sometimes decades, before a break. The break might be a new DNA test, a genealogy match, a confession, a witness who finally spoke or a detective who reread the file with fresh eyes. Cold cases show how much can change with time: technology improves, loyalties fade and people who once kept silent decide to talk. Each story follows the original investigation, the long silence and the work that finally brought an answer to the families who waited.

Cases in this category

The Vanishing Act — Elmer Crawford

The Vanishing Act

In July 1970 the Crawford family car was found at the bottom of Loch Ard Gorge with a mother and her three children inside, staged to look like a murder-suicide. Their father, Elmer Crawford, was seen at home that day and never again.

One of Their Own — Sherri Rasmussen

One of Their Own

Nurse Sherri Rasmussen was beaten, bitten and shot in her Van Nuys condo three months after her wedding. Police called it a burglary gone wrong. Twenty-three years later, the saliva in the bite mark led to one of their own detectives.

The Gum Ruse — Mitchell Gaff

The Gum Ruse

Susan Vesey celebrated her twenty-first birthday in Everett, Washington, in July 1980. By morning she was dead on her bedroom floor, her infant son unharmed beside her — and the case would stay cold for decades.

The Sleepover — Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman

The Sleepover

Ashley Freeman turned sixteen on December 29, 1999, and her best friend Lauria Bible stayed over at the family trailer near Welch, Oklahoma. Before dawn the trailer was in flames, and the two girls were gone.

The Speed Freaks — The Speed Freak Killers

The Speed Freaks

Wesley Shermantine and Loren Herzog grew up inseparable across Fine Road in tiny Linden, California. What the two friends did in the methamphetamine years would leave San Joaquin County digging for victims decades later.

Two Hundred Feet Below — Scott White

Two Hundred Feet Below

In 1988, the body of brilliant American mathematician Scott Johnson was found at the base of the cliffs near Manly, Australia. Police called it a suicide — a story that would take three decades to undo.

Middle Mountain — Mark Redwine

Middle Mountain

Thirteen-year-old Dylan Redwine flew to Colorado for a court-ordered Thanksgiving visit with his father, Mark, at a remote house near Vallecito Reservoir. By morning, the boy who always texted back was gone.

The Wishing Well — Betty Lou Beets

The Wishing Well

When Jimmy Don Beets's boat was found drifting empty on Cedar Creek Lake with his heart pills on the seat, it looked like a Texas fishing tragedy. His wife, Betty Lou, knew the lake wasn't holding the answer.

The Vanishing Act — John List

The Vanishing Act

When police climbed through a window of the darkened List mansion in Westfield, New Jersey, in December 1971, the house was ice cold, the family had been 'away' for a month — and church hymns were still playing over the intercom.

The I-70 Rapist — Douglas Belt

The I-70 Rapist

A beeping smoke detector in a vacant Wichita apartment led a maintenance man to a scene that broke veteran detectives — and reopened the trail of a predator who had stalked the highways along I-70.

The Perfect Murder — Maria Baumer

The Perfect Murder

Mushroom foragers in a Bavarian forest near Regensburg found bones fused with hardened quicklime — remains someone had tried to chemically erase. Christian F. believed he had committed the perfect murder.

The Plastic Roses — Gail Smith

The Plastic Roses

When police forced entry into Gail Smith's Berryville, Virginia, home after four days of silence, her prized garden was rotting on the vine — and the answers lay with the two people closest to her.

The Cleveland Monster — Ariel Castro

The Cleveland Monster

Michelle Knight was rushing to a custody hearing in 2002 when a familiar Cleveland school bus driver named Ariel Castro offered her a ride — with a quick stop at his ordinary-looking house on Seymour Avenue.

The Hammer Killer — Alex Christopher Ewing

The Hammer Killer

In January 1984, residents of Aurora, Colorado, began waking to a nightmare: an intruder standing over their beds with a hammer. The attacks were only the beginning of a spree that would take decades to unravel.

The Smooth Talker — Roy Melanson

The Smooth Talker

On a July night in 1974, a charming stranger lingered at the bar of Fagiani's Cocktail Lounge in Napa as Anita Andrews closed up alone. It would take decades to learn who the smooth talker really was.

The Animal — Jerry Walter McFadden

The Animal

In July 1979, Rose Hlavka came home to a silent Portland apartment and found her twenty-year-old sister Anna Marie strangled with a clock radio cord — a crime so cold it would wait decades for an answer.

Blue Earth Jane Doe — Robert Leroy Nelson

Blue Earth Jane Doe

Michelle Busha fled her strict Bay City, Texas home and called her family from the road — until the calls stopped in the spring of 1980. That May, a young woman found murdered near Blue Earth, Minnesota, was buried without a name, a Jane Doe for decades.

The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders — The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders

The Limburg Schoolgirl Murders

Best friends Jasmin and Yvonne, both sixteen, left a German discotheque at 3:00 a.m. in October 1994 and accepted a ride from a friendly middle-aged couple — a motherly woman and her quiet husband. Neither girl made it home to Limburg.

Fox Hollow Farm — Herb Baumeister

Fox Hollow Farm

Exploring the woods behind his family's eighteen-acre Indiana estate in 1994, thirteen-year-old Erich Baumeister carried a human skull back to the house. His father Herb had an explanation — one that would hold for two more years.

The Long Walk Home — Richard Archibeque

The Long Walk Home

Seventeen-year-old Mary Quigley never made it home from a back-to-school keg party in Santa Clara, California, in September 1977. For decades the question of who followed her into the night went unanswered — until DNA pointed to a name: Richard Archibeque.

The Stanford Cold Case — Arlis Perry

The Stanford Cold Case

'Hey, we've got a stiff in here.' Security guard Stephen Crawford's oddly detached radio call summoned police to Stanford Memorial Church at dawn in October 1974, where newlywed Arlis Perry lay dead beneath the stained glass. The hunt for her killer would span forty-four years.

The Pink Notebook — Tracey Richter

The Pink Notebook

Tracey Richter told the 911 dispatcher that two intruders had attacked her in her Early, Iowa home and that she had shot one to save her children. The dead man was a quiet twenty-year-old neighbor — and a pink notebook would tell a far stranger story.

The Hudson Murders — Dan O’Connell

The Hudson Murders

The St. Croix County medical examiner walked into O'Connell Family Funeral Home in Hudson, Wisconsin, expecting routine paperwork — and found funeral director Dan O'Connell and a young intern shot dead. Hudson hadn't seen a murder in twenty-four years.

The Bathtub Killer — Dale Scheanette

The Bathtub Killer

Schoolteacher Christine Vu was found bound and drowned in her own bathtub at Arlington, Texas's Peartree Apartments in 1996. When another young woman was found the same way, police realized a predator was choosing victims frighteningly close to home.

The Christadelphian — Gary Schaefer

The Christadelphian

Springfield, Vermont, seemed like a postcard New England town until thirteen-year-old Sherry Nastasia vanished in August 1979. Over the next four years more young girls were taken — and the clue that finally broke the case was a church sweatshirt.

Sacred Trust — Danny Croteau

Sacred Trust

Thirteen-year-old Danny Croteau was found dead along the Chicopee River in 1972, and suspicion quickly settled on a family friend no one dared accuse: Father Richard Lavigne, the parish priest. The case would stay open for nearly fifty years.

The Bedroom Basher — Gerald Parker

The Bedroom Basher

While Marine Kevin Green stepped out for late-night food in September 1979, someone entered his Tustin, California apartment and savagely beat his pregnant wife, Dianna. She survived with shattered memories — and what she remembered would cost Kevin sixteen years.

Harvard Trained — Amy Bishop

Harvard Trained

Amy Bishop grew up in Braintree, Massachusetts, forever in the shadow of her effortlessly brilliant younger brother, Seth. What happened between them one afternoon in 1986 would be ruled an accident — and stay buried for more than two decades.

A Killer Breakthrough — Colin Pitchfork

A Killer Breakthrough

Fifteen-year-old Lynda Mann took the Black Pad footpath to a babysitting job in Narborough, England, one November evening in 1983 and never came home. Solving her murder — and a second one nearby — would require a scientific technique no police force had ever used.

The Cape Coral Monster — Joseph Zieler

The Cape Coral Monster

Jan Cornell rushed home before her early-morning shift in May 1990 to find her Cape Coral townhouse silent — her eleven-year-old daughter Robin and roommate Lisa Story inside. The DNA left behind would wait twenty-six years for a match.

The Frame-up — Pam Hupp

The Frame-up

Pam Hupp was the last person to see her friend Betsy Faria alive — and the newly named beneficiary of her life insurance. When Betsy's husband Russ was convicted of her murder, the story seemed over. It was only beginning.

The Bayou Butcher — Sean Gillis

The Bayou Butcher

For five years, women vanished from the night streets of Baton Rouge while Sean Gillis lived quietly with a girlfriend who had no idea where he went after dark. The break in the case came from something as ordinary as a set of rare car tires.

The Zombie Hunter — Bryan Patrick Miller

The Zombie Hunter

The day before her twenty-second birthday, Angela Brosso set off on a five-mile bike ride along a Phoenix canal near her home and never came back. For more than two decades, the canal killings haunted the Sunnyslope neighborhood.

The Hitchhiker Slayer — Thor Christiansen

The Hitchhiker Slayer

In 1970s Isla Vista, hitchhiking was simply how UC Santa Barbara students got around — until young women with outstretched thumbs began to vanish. When Jacqueline Rook missed Thanksgiving with her family, the community's free-spirited trust began to crumble.

Mr. Big — Brett Peter Cowan

Mr. Big

Thirteen-year-old Daniel Morcombe stood beneath a Queensland overpass in December 2003, waiting for a bus that had broken down. When the next bus arrived ten minutes later, Daniel — and the man seen lingering behind him — had vanished.

The Fifth Nail — Joseph Edward Duncan III

The Fifth Nail

A Wolf Lodge, Idaho, man called 911 about a strange white truck on his property; hours later he called back, frantic, after finding blood smeared on his neighbors' door. Inside the Groene home, deputies found bodies bound with duct tape — and the youngest children gone.

The Santa Fe Strangler — David Bruce Morton

The Santa Fe Strangler

A maid opening room 205 of a Santa Fe motel in November 1983 found a twenty-two-year-old woman strangled with a red handkerchief, her hands bound with a pillowcase. When secretary Teri Mulvaney was murdered months later, her family already had a name: David Bruce Morton.

Vanished Innocence — Mona Rae Minyard

Vanished Innocence

Two days after Christmas 1962, six-year-old Mona Rae Minyard walked to Portland's Three Brothers Market with a five-dollar bill and her mother's short grocery list. She never came home — and suspicion settled on Joseph Walton Holmes, the man who lived just across the field.

A Sad Holiday Season — John Taylor

A Sad Holiday Season

Sixteen-year-old Leanne Tiernan said goodbye to her best friend after a day of Christmas shopping in Leeds and took the unlit shortcut through Houghley Gill. Police searched 1,400 houses, drained three miles of canals, and questioned 140 men — and found no trace of her.

The Christmas Tree Farm Murders — Ricky Riffe

The Christmas Tree Farm Murders

Ed and Minnie Maurin, in their eighties and famous for the Christmas luncheon at their Ethel, Washington tree-farm home, were missing when friends arrived to set up the 1985 party. Inside the locked house, bank statements lay scattered across the bathroom floor.

Worlds Worst Mom — Theresa Knorr

Worlds Worst Mom

Driving near Lake Tahoe at dawn in June 1984, Maybel Harrison spotted flames beside the highway: a young woman burning on a makeshift pyre, bound, gagged, and unidentifiable. Nearly a decade later, Terry Knorr told police a story about her own family that no one believed.

The Murder of Stephanie Hebert — Stephanie Hebert

The Murder of Stephanie Hebert

Five-year-old Stephanie Hebert set off for a friend's house three doors down Aster Lane in Waggaman, Louisiana, in June 1978 — and never made it. More than 150 deputies searched the canals and levees for the little girl in baby-blue glasses without finding a trace.

Angelic — Daniel Holdom

Angelic

In 2008, Karlie Pearce-Stevenson left remote Alice Springs with her toddler, Khandalyce, and a boyfriend fifteen years her senior, Daniel Holdom. A year later her calls and texts home stopped — though her bank account stayed strangely active.

The Killer Clown — Sheila Keen-Warren

The Killer Clown

Just before 11:00 a.m., Marlene answered the doorbell of her Florida home to find a clown in an orange wig holding balloons and a basket of flowers — a gift, she assumed, from her husband Michael Warren. What happened next took decades to unravel.

The Piggy Palace — Robert Pickton

The Piggy Palace

Women had been vanishing from Vancouver's Downtown Eastside since 1983 — so many, and so invisible, that authorities took nearly a decade to notice. The trail eventually led out of the city to a pig farm and a man named Robert 'Willy' Pickton.

Like Mother, Like Son — Cheryl Kunkle

Like Mother, Like Son

In Pennsylvania's Pocono Mountains, Cheryl Kunkle raised her son Greg Rowe on resentment and control. When sixteen-year-old Kristin Fisher refused the abortion Greg demanded and gave birth to baby Kaylee, mother and son came to share far more than a grudge.

Dead in the Water — Oba Chandler

Dead in the Water

Jo Rogers and her daughters Michelle and Christe left their Ohio dairy farm for their first real vacation, snapping photos from a hotel room overlooking Tampa Bay — days before the Coast Guard began pulling bodies, roped to concrete blocks, from the water.

The Mousse Can Killer — Robert Mark Edwards

The Mousse Can Killer

Robert Mark Edwards was raised on beatings and addiction and turned early to burglary — and when a woman was found beaten and strangled, the bloody can of hair styling mousse left on her bed became the case's strangest piece of evidence.

Divine Justice — William Cosden

Divine Justice

In a Pacific Northwest decade haunted by vanishing girls — several later confirmed as Ted Bundy victims — fourteen-year-old Kathy Devine's 1973 disappearance near Olympia sat unsolved for decades, filed under the wrong killer.

Cold Storage Killer — John Famalaro

Cold Storage Killer

After a Morrissey concert in June 1991, Denise Huber's gray Honda Accord was found abandoned on the Corona del Mar highway with a flat rear tire, just miles from her Newport Beach home — and for three years there was no trace of her at all.

Murder in the Sacristy — Gerald Robinson

Murder in the Sacristy

On Holy Saturday 1980 — her seventy-second birthday — Sister Margaret Ann Pahl went early to prepare the chapel at Toledo's Mercy Hospital, intending to confront Father Gerald Robinson about his sermon; a bloodstained cloth on the chapel floor was the first sign something was wrong.

The Copper Gulch Killer — Candace Hiltz

The Copper Gulch Killer

Teenage prodigy Candace Hiltz was bound for Stanford Law when she was found shot dead in her family's remote Copper Gulch, Colorado home — a still-unsolved case that took a strange turn when a delinquent storage unit went up for auction.

The Alligator Theory — Mike Williams

The Alligator Theory

On the morning of his sixth wedding anniversary, Mike Williams set out alone to hunt ducks among the stumps of Lake Seminole and never returned — and with no body to recover, investigators reasoned the lake's alligators had left nothing to find.

The Canal Killer — John Sweeney

The Canal Killer

In February 2001, two boys fishing in London's Regent's Canal snagged a duffel bag weighted with bricks — the first of six bags divers would recover, holding a woman whose missing head, hands, and feet made her nearly impossible to identify.

The Tacoma Murders — Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian

The Tacoma Murders

In 1986, months apart, young Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian were murdered near Tacoma parks just three miles from each other — crimes so similar police assumed one killer, until DNA told a stranger story that took decades to finish.

The Girl in the Barrel — Howard Elkins

The Girl in the Barrel

During a final walkthrough before the sale of a Jericho, New York house in September 1999, the buyer insisted on removing a 355-pound barrel that had sat wedged in the crawlspace for decades — a barrel the seller had never once opened.

No Body, No Doubt — Bryan Stewart

No Body, No Doubt

When Jamie Laiaddee disappeared from Arizona, prosecutor Juan Martinez — later famous for the Jodi Arias trial — took her boyfriend to court without a body, without physical evidence, and with a defendant who answered to two different names.

Models Inc. — Lester Jones

Models Inc.

On June 28, 2007, Paige Birgfeld drove home from a picnic with her high-school-sweetheart ex-husband and vanished — and the search for the Grand Junction, Colorado mother of three uncovered a secret life no one around her suspected.

The Green Chain Killer — Robert Napper

The Green Chain Killer

When Pauline Lasham told police her son Robert Napper had confessed to a rape near Plumstead Common, they checked their records, found nothing, and let it go — while the attacks along London's Green Chain Walk were only beginning.

The Burning Barrel — Fred Grabbe

The Burning Barrel

On a July evening in 1981, Charlotte Grabbe never came back from the soybean fields of her family's Marshall, Illinois farm — her tractor parked in the shed, her lunch box untouched, and her divorce from the violent Fred Grabbe still unfinished.

A Doctor's Blood — Dr. John Schneeberger

A Doctor's Blood

On Halloween night 1992 in tiny Kipling, Saskatchewan, a distraught young mother sought help from the town's beloved Dr. John Schneeberger — and what she remembered from that examination room would pit her word against his DNA.

Home Alive — Jesus MezquiaAudio / Video Coming Soon

Home Alive

Mia Zapata, the electrifying voice of Seattle punk band The Gits, left a Capitol Hill bar alone on a July night in 1993. Finding out what happened on her walk home would take a decade and a science that didn't exist yet.

The Bedford Cold Case — Arthur MasseiAudio / Video Coming Soon

The Bedford Cold Case

Bank president Raymond Scheublin came home to Bedford, Massachusetts, in June 1971 to find his wife Natalie bound and dead at the bottom of the cellar stairs. The case would sit cold for half a century.

The Stranger — The Eugene Serial MurdersAudio / Video Coming Soon

The Stranger

Gladys Hensley, 62, was a quiet fixture of her Eugene, Oregon, senior apartment complex until someone sliced through her window screen in the night. Finding the stranger who climbed in would take decades.

What the Woods Kept — Marcus SanfratelloAudio / Video Coming Soon

What the Woods Kept

Terry Peroni was last seen walking into the Oregon woods with Marcus Sanfratello after a Fourth of July party in 1983. What searchers eventually found along the Illinois River kept the case alive for forty years.

The I-65 Killer — The I-65 KillerAudio / Video Coming Soon

The I-65 Killer

Night auditor Vicki Heath was found behind the Super 8 in Elizabethtown, Kentucky, in 1987 — one victim of a predator working the motels along Interstate 65 whose name would stay hidden for thirty-five years.

California — Alissa TurneyAudio / Video Coming Soon

California

Seventeen-year-old Alissa Turney had $1,800 saved for a summer in California when she disappeared from Phoenix on the last day of her junior year — leaving behind her stepfather, a former sheriff's deputy, and questions that lasted decades.

Amok — Krystian BalaAudio / Video Coming Soon

Amok

Polish ad-agency owner Dariusz Janiszewski walked out to meet a mystery client in Wrocław in November 2000 and never returned — and the strangest clue would surface years later in a novel written by Krystian Bala.

Call Me Clark — Clark RockefellerAudio / Video Coming Soon

Call Me Clark

The elegant young 'baronet' handing out calling cards in San Marino called himself Christopher Mountbatten Chichester. He was really Christian Karl Gerhartsreiter, a Bavarian teenager reinventing himself — and his greatest performance hid a body.

Related categories

Membership

Every case, narrated.

Hundreds of true crime cases, with new cases every week. The first three minutes of every case are free, or try 5 full stories free for 3 days.

Start your 3-day free trial then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year