All cases
Sign in
The Christadelphian — Gary Schaefer

Gary Schaefer: The Christadelphian

The Christadelphian:AccusedGary Schaefer·VictimsKatie Richards·Sherry Nastasia·Teresa Fenton·Deanna Buxton

Case at a glance

When
August 1979 to April 1983
Where
Springfield and Chester, Vermont
Perpetrator
Gary Lee Schaefer
Outcome
Pleaded no contest in the murder of Katy Richards and sentenced to 30 years to life; never convicted in the deaths of Sherry Nastasia or Theresa Fenton; died in a Kentucky prison in 2023

The case

Gary Lee Schaefer was a car mechanic in Springfield, Vermont, who belonged to the small Christadelphian church. Between 1979 and 1983 three Springfield girls were killed. Sherry Nastasia, 13, disappeared on August 28, 1979, after getting into a dark green car, possibly a Firebird; her remains were found that December. Theresa Fenton, 12, was abducted on a bike ride on August 29, 1981, and died of a beating two days later.

In November 1982 a man picked up 17-year-old Deana Buxton in Chester and threatened her with a shotgun; she escaped when he stopped at a store. On April 9, 1983, 11-year-old Catherine “Katy” Richards was walking with her friend Rachel Zeitz when a car that had circled them several times pulled up. Rachel got away, and Katy was found dead the following day. A church leader said the sketch resembled Schaefer and had seen him driving nearby, and a red Christadelphian sweatshirt matching Rachel’s description turned up at his home. He was arrested on April 11.

In December 1983 Schaefer pleaded no contest in the Richards killing and the Buxton case, and in January 1984 was sentenced to 30 years to life. He confessed to killing Theresa but had been granted immunity. A charge in Sherry’s death was dropped after a judge threw out a hypnosis-based confession. He died in a Kentucky prison on November 26, 2023, at 72.

Case photographs

Gary Lee Schaefer
Gary Lee Schaefer
Gary Lee Schaefer
Gary Lee Schaefer
Gary Lee Schaefer
Gary Lee Schaefer
Gary Lee Schaefer
Gary Lee Schaefer
Sherry Nastasia
Sherry Nastasia

Where it happened

Springfield, where three girls were killed between 1979 and 1983

Jason Neal has been writing true crime since 2019 and is the author of the True Crime Case Histories book series.

The full written account of this case is in True Crime Case Histories: Volume 16: Book · Paperback · Audiobook

Loading…
Preview over

There’s more to this one.

Start a 3-day free trial and hear the rest of this story, plus any four others. Cancel any time before it ends and you pay nothing.

Start your free trial 3 days free, then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year