These are crimes that began or played out online: killers who met victims through dating sites and chat rooms, people radicalized on the internet, cases built on messages and search histories, and online personas that hid who someone really was. Digital evidence has become central to modern investigations, and in many of these cases a phone, a laptop or a social media account told the story the suspect would not. Each case follows how investigators traced the online trail back to a real person.

Online, a 21-year-old pizza delivery driver from Dearborn Heights told the young woman he hoped to marry that he planned to shoot up a Detroit church. She was not who she said she was. She worked for the FBI.

Jamie Faith was walking the dog with his wife Jennifer on their quiet Dallas street when a masked gunman shot him seven times, then turned on her with duct tape. Doorbell cameras up and down South Waverly Drive caught everything.

Ina and David Steiner ran a small newsletter covering eBay from their Natick, Massachusetts home. In August 2019 came the strange subscriptions, the threats, and a preserved fetal pig — a campaign traced somewhere no one expected.

The Craigslist ad promised a caretaker job on a 688-acre Ohio cattle farm — a fresh start for men down on their luck. The farm didn't exist, and the man behind the ad was known around Akron as Chaplain Rich.

Behind a closed bedroom door in suburban Melbourne, a quiet former babysitter named Matthew Graham ran the dark web's most notorious child-abuse network under the name Lux — until investigators on three continents started pulling the thread.

A fishing family on a remote South Australian beach heard the screaming first — a bloodied Brazilian backpacker named Beatriz bursting from the Salt Creek scrubland, begging them to save her friend Lena from the man still out there.

Sixteen-year-old Preston Lord was walking away from a Halloween party in Queen Creek, Arizona, when a mob of teenagers descended. The beating exposed months of organized violence festering beneath Gilbert's wealthy suburban surface.

Derek Medina was a regular at the Miami Denny's where single mother Jennifer Alfonso worked the graveyard shift — generous with tips, obsessed with his phone, and far more dangerous than his self-help books suggested.

When Stephen Allwine calmly reported that his wife Amy had shot herself in their Cottage Grove, Minnesota home, the scene almost looked right. But the pieces didn't fit — and the trail led investigators somewhere few had ever gone: the dark web's murder-for-hire sites.

On a snowy November night in 2010, an RCMP officer watched a black pickup fishtail out of a deserted logging road near British Columbia's infamous Highway of Tears. The young driver, Cody Legebokoff, had blood on his face — and a story that didn't add up.

A jogger's trembling 911 call one October morning in 2016 reported a body on a trail in St. Joseph, Missouri's Krug Park. Seventeen-year-old Kaytlin Root had been lured there by a Facebook message from someone calling herself 'Amanda Panda.'

When nineteen-year-old Natalie Bollinger disappeared from Broomfield, Colorado, in December 2017, everyone pointed to the homeless man she had taken out a restraining order against. Then investigators found the Craigslist ad Natalie herself had posted.

Sasha Marsden of the quiet village of Staining, England, was known for spontaneous dance moves and an infectious sense of humor. In nearby Blackpool, a hotel job offer from a man named David Minto was waiting — an offer that concealed something monstrous.

Twenty-one-year-old British backpacker Grace Millane was partway through her round-the-world gap year when she matched with a man named Jesse on Tinder in Auckland. On December 1, 2018, she agreed to meet him for drinks — and was never seen again.

'Hi, how are you? I've seen your picture. You're very pretty.' The Facebook message that reached fifteen-year-old Kayleigh Haywood on Halloween 2015 came from twenty-seven-year-old Luke Harlow — and thirteen days of hidden messages convinced her she was loved.

Grant Amato spent more than $2,000 a night on Silvie, a Bulgarian cam model he'd never met but called his girlfriend, inventing a life of BMWs and big houses. His real, devoted family in Chuluota, Florida had no idea what his obsession would cost them.

A first date arranged on plentyoffish.com came with strange instructions — sneak in under the half-open garage door — and Gilles Tetreault stumbled out of that dark garage having barely escaped a man in a hockey mask following a script.

Elaine O'Hara vanished near Dublin in August 2012, the day after her release from a psychiatric hospital — and the investigation that unfolded over the next three years exposed one of the most shocking crimes in Irish history.

NYPD officer Gilberto Valle had a wife, a baby daughter, and a spotless record. Then his wife looked at their shared laptop and found the conversations he was having after his shifts ended — about the women in his life.

Tyler Clementi arrived at Rutgers a gifted violinist quietly starting a new life. Weeks into his freshman year, his roommate Dharun Ravi pointed a webcam at Room 30 — and Tyler found out what it had seen.

Polish ad-agency owner Dariusz Janiszewski walked out to meet a mystery client in Wrocław in November 2000 and never returned — and the strangest clue would surface years later in a novel written by Krystian Bala.
No cases tagged this yet.
Back to all casesHundreds of true crime cases, with new cases every week. The first three minutes of every case are free, or try 5 full stories free for 3 days.
Start your 3-day free trial then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year