In these cases a diagnosed mental illness shaped the crime, the investigation or the verdict. Some defendants were found not guilty by reason of insanity or unfit to stand trial; others were convicted despite serious illness, and some cases turned on whether the illness was real at all. The stories look at the evidence, the expert testimony and the questions courts had to answer, and at what happened to each person afterward, whether in prison, a secure hospital or eventually released.

For four years a stalker called the Poet terrorized Wichita secretary Ruth Finley with rhyming letters, cut phone lines and a stabbing, while police watched her house and never saw an intruder. Then one letter described the police chief’s wife.

A week after his wife asked for a divorce, former firefighter William Gravlin took a taxi back to the family home in Troy, Michigan. By morning his wife and six children were dead, each covered with a blanket and a note of apology.

Anatoly Moskvin was Nizhny Novgorod’s leading expert on its cemeteries. When police finally traced years of desecrated children’s graves to his family’s flat in 2011, they found 26 “dolls” among his books.

Gary Heidnik ran his own church and a half-million-dollar stock account from a run-down house in North Philadelphia. In the basement he kept six women chained in a pit he had dug. One of them talked her way out.

Best friends Jasmin and Yvonne, both sixteen, left a German discotheque at 3:00 a.m. in October 1994 and accepted a ride from a friendly middle-aged couple — a motherly woman and her quiet husband. Neither girl made it home to Limburg.

In an Idaho Falls group home for men rebuilding their lives, German-born Hans Woerrlein — 'extremely smart, super sweet' — was paired with a quiet new roommate named Douglass Taylor. Their late-night talks about religion and secret societies took a dark turn in March 2020.

Swedish twins Ursula and Sabina Eriksson lived quiet, unremarkable lives an ocean apart for forty years. Then, in May 2008, within hours of reuniting in Ireland, something shifted — setting off one of the most bizarre and baffling cases ever caught on camera.

Pizza deliveryman Brian Wells robbed an Erie, Pennsylvania bank with a bomb locked around his neck, pleading with police that someone had forced him into a deadly scavenger hunt. Minutes later, on live television, the collar began to beep.

When David Lutz came home to his Reading, Pennsylvania apartment at 3:30 a.m., he found his roommate Stanley Detweiler decapitated — and the word 'REDRUM' scrawled on the wall in blood. Even the police chief asked: what kind of lunatic would do this?

Millionaire Christopher Foster spent August 25, 2008, shooting clay pigeons and relaxing at a neighbor's barbecue with his wife Jill and daughter Kirstie. By sunrise, their Shropshire mansion, Osbaston House, was a smoldering ruin concealing the truth of his collapsing empire.

On Mother's Day 2018, hairstylist Joleen Cummings failed to pick up her three children in Yulee, Florida. Suspicion fell on a coworker at Tangles Hair Salon — a woman who, it turned out, had lived under eighteen different names across fourteen states.

Days before Christmas 2013, Ilona Flint and Salvatore Belvedere were shot in a San Diego mall parking lot while searching for Salvatore's missing brother Gianni — Ilona's fiancé. Three weeks later, Gianni's car turned up a hundred miles away with a terrible secret in the trunk.

In the months before Mother's Day 2017, Joshua Webb of Colton, Oregon, told friends that a black box in his garage was recording him and that voices in his head were growing louder. What he carried into an Estacada grocery store that day defied belief.

The day before her twenty-second birthday, Angela Brosso set off on a five-mile bike ride along a Phoenix canal near her home and never came back. For more than two decades, the canal killings haunted the Sunnyslope neighborhood.

Coworkers at the Goleta mail facility knew Jennifer San Marco as the quiet sorter who argued with someone who wasn't there. After being forced out of her job, she moved to New Mexico, bought a handgun — and in January 2006, she came back.

To her Pittsburgh-area church and school colleagues, Laurel Schlemmer was sweet, kind-hearted, and devout — a woman who had never wanted the children her husband Mark insisted on. One morning, with their grandmother watching television downstairs, Laurel ran a bath for the boys.

Algebra teacher Colleen Ritzer stayed after class at Danvers High School to help any student who needed it. On October 22, 2013, fourteen-year-old Philip Chism — a quiet newcomer from Tennessee — was in her final class of the day.

By the time British banker Rurik Jutting reached Hong Kong — a vice president who cried at his desk and snorted cocaine through the workday — the boy raised to believe he was a 'great one' was unraveling. Room 3109 was waiting.

Born to a bootlegger's family in small-town Missouri, Charles Ray Hatcher grew from a bullied, brutalized boy into a cold and remorseless predator. His life became a revolving door through America's prisons — and the danger returned each time the door swung open.

Karen and Kraig Kahler had the marriage other couples tried to emulate. Then, the Saturday after Thanksgiving, a neighbor in Burlingame, Kansas, watched a man park a red SUV outside great-grandmother Dorothy Wight's farmhouse and stomp toward the porch carrying something large.

When Julie Paterson vanished after a trip to a Darlington pub in April 1998, her boyfriend Alan knew she would never miss a visit with her daughter — and weeks later, a police dog led its handler into the overgrown garden of a house that wasn't abandoned after all.

In a Pacific Northwest decade haunted by vanishing girls — several later confirmed as Ted Bundy victims — fourteen-year-old Kathy Devine's 1973 disappearance near Olympia sat unsolved for decades, filed under the wrong killer.

Ed Gingerich never fit the plain, machine-less life of his Old Order Amish community, so Bishop Rudy Shetler arranged a marriage to his niece Katie — a match that ended in the tragedy of March 18, 1993, one so dark much of Rockdale Township's Amish moved away.

Sally Challen was fifteen when she fell for car dealer Richard Challen, and she stayed devoted through four decades of his cruelty and control — until a Saturday lunch at their Surrey home ended with the hammer she had carried in her handbag.

Nine-year-old Elizabeth Olten set off on the four-house walk home from a neighbor's in tiny St. Martin, Missouri, and never arrived — and her cell phone signal pointed hundreds of searchers into the dark woods directly behind their homes.

When Pauline Lasham told police her son Robert Napper had confessed to a rape near Plumstead Common, they checked their records, found nothing, and let it go — while the attacks along London's Green Chain Walk were only beginning.

Elaine O'Hara vanished near Dublin in August 2012, the day after her release from a psychiatric hospital — and the investigation that unfolded over the next three years exposed one of the most shocking crimes in Irish history.

Carole Sund planned every detail of her February 1999 trip to Yosemite with daughter Juli and Argentine exchange student Silvina Pelosso. When the three vanished with their rented red Pontiac, the search led to a man no one suspected.
No cases tagged this yet.
Back to all casesHundreds of true crime cases, with new cases every week. The first three minutes of every case are free, or try 5 full stories free for 3 days.
Start your 3-day free trial then $9.99/month or $79.99 a year